The Babaʾī revolt crushed at Malya by a Seljuk army with Frankish mercenaries (1240). Börklüce Mustafa crucified at Ephesus and his disciples killed; Sheikh Bedreddin hanged (1416). Kızılbaş registered and killed or imprisoned before Chaldiran, reported at forty thousand (1513–14). The Janissary corps destroyed, about 6,000 executed by official count, the Bektashi order banned and its leaders executed or exiled (1826). Every lodge closed by law (1925); 35 killed at an Alevi festival in Sivas (1993).
CONNECTIONS · 1221–1826 · RELIGION · From Khurasani Persianate Sufi → Anatolian Turkic (Seljuk Rum and the beyliks)

Khurasani Sufis remake Anatolian Islam (c. 1300) — and who paid

Refugees from the Mongol conquest of Khurasan brought the Sufi order to Seljuk Anatolia. Two orders grew from them: the Mevlevi, Persian-speaking and courtly, and the Bektashi, Turkish-speaking, which became the religion of the Janissaries. For six centuries the dervish lodge settled the frontier, fed travellers and gave Anatolian Muslims their faith. The state endowed the lodges, massacred the dervishes who rebelled, persecuted the Kızılbaş, destroyed the Bektashis in 1826 and closed every lodge in 1925.

In 1228 a preacher from Balkh named Bahāʾ al-Dīn Walad, driven west by the Mongol conquest of Khurasan, settled in Konya with his son Jalāl al-Dīn — the poet the world calls Rūmī. Refugees like them brought the Sufi order to Seljuk Anatolia, a plateau where most people were still Christians. Around 1300 Rūmī's son Sultan Walad turned his father's circle into the Mevlevi order, while Turkmen dervishes of the pastures gathered around the memory of Hacı Bektaş, the saint who would become patron of the Janissaries. The dervish lodge became the institution that settled the Ottoman frontier and converted its people. It also became suspect: the Turkmen dervishes who rose in 1240 and 1416 were massacred, the Kızılbaş persecuted from 1511, the Bektashi order banned in 1826, and every lodge in Turkey closed by law in 1925.

An Ottoman manuscript painting in three registers: at the top a cenotaph under a red and gold cloth with turbans at its head; in the middle a kneeling official and a seated sheikh holding a book; below, about fifteen dervishes in tall brown felt caps turning with raised arms on a blue patterned floor, with seated musicians playing frame drums.
Mevlevi dervishes turn in the semā beside Rūmī's tomb in Konya while the Ottoman commander Lala Mustafa Paşa kneels before the lodge's sheikh, in a miniature from Muṣṭafā ʿĀlī's Nusretnâme, the illustrated history of the eastern campaign of 1578, painted c. 1584. Three centuries after Rūmī's death the order his son built had become part of the Ottoman state's own ceremonial.
Gelibolulu Muṣṭafā ʿĀlī (author; anonymous Ottoman court painter). Nusretnâme, Lala Mustafa Paşa visiting the tomb of Mevlânâ, fol. 36a, c. 1584. Topkapı Palace Museum Library, Istanbul (H. 1365). Public domain via Wikimedia Commons. · Public domain

Before: a Christian plateau with a Turkish frontier

A Muslim minority on a Christian plateau

In 1200 the central Anatolian plateau had been under Turkish rule for more than a century, and most of the people living on it were still Christians. The Seljuk victory over the Byzantine emperor Romanos IV Diogenes at Manzikert in 1071 had opened Asia Minor to Turkmen pastoral tribes, and by the 1080s a branch of the Seljuk house had set up a sultanate in Nicaea and then, after the First Crusade drove it inland, at Konya, the old Iconium. The Byzantines called it the sultanate of Rum — of the Romans — and the name stuck. But conquest is not conversion. Speros Vryonis, whose Decline of Medieval Hellenism in Asia Minor (1971) remains the fullest study of the process, concluded that "it is highly probable that the majority of the Anatolian Christian population remained in Asia Minor fifty years after Manzikert", and that the towns kept Greek, Armenian and Syriac bishops, monasteries and markets well into the thirteenth century.1 Greek remained a language of the street in Konya, Kayseri and Sivas; Armenian dominated the southeast; Syriac Christians ran monasteries around Malatya.

Over this population sat two Muslim societies that barely shared a language. The first was the court and the towns: sultans who took Persian epic names (Kaykhusraw, Kayqubād, Kaykāʾūs), a chancery and literature conducted in Persian, judges and madrasa teachers recruited from Iran and Syria, and an architecture of caravanserais, hospitals and madrasas paid for by pious endowments (vaqf). The second was the Turkmen pasture: Oghuz-speaking tribes who wintered on the plains and summered on the high pastures, whose Islam was a matter of oaths, saints and inherited custom rather than of law books, and whose loyalty to the sultan in Konya was conditional.2

A Persian court in Konya

The Seljuk court of Rum was, in its own self-image, a provincial capital of the Persianate world. Claude Cahen, in La Turquie pré-ottomane (1988), describes the sultans of the early thirteenth century — above all ʿAlāʾ al-Dīn Kayqubād I (r. 1220–1237) — as builders of a state on Iranian models: a Persian-language bureaucracy, a taxed peasantry, a network of caravan routes linking the Mediterranean ports of Antalya and Alanya to the Black Sea at Sinop and the Iranian plateau beyond.2 What that court did not yet have was an organised Sufism of its own. There were individual mystics, preachers and hermits; there were lodges endowed here and there; there was no order — no ṭarīqa with a named founder, a fixed ritual, a chain of succession and branch houses in other towns.

That institution had been built further east. In Khurasan and Transoxiana — Nishapur, Herat, Balkh, Bukhara, Samarkand — the twelfth century had produced the Sufi order as a transmissible organisation: a master (shaykh, in Persian pīr) at the head of a lineage (silsila) that ran back through named teachers to the Prophet, a lodge (khānaqāh) supported by endowments, a novice who swore allegiance and received a cloak, and a body of Persian-language teaching that made the whole system portable. This is the culture the atlas records as Khurasani Persianate Sufism, the same network that a century earlier had carried Islam into north India.

What the Turkmen believed

On the pastures the religious life was older and less literate. The Turkmen tribes had converted to Islam in Central Asia during the tenth and eleventh centuries, largely through itinerant preachers and holy men, and had kept much of what had come before: reverence for ancestors and for the graves of holy men, vows made at springs and trees, a figure of the baba or ata — a charismatic holy man who healed, blessed, cursed and led. Fuad Köprülü, whose Türk Edebiyatında İlk Mutasavvıflar (Early Mystics in Turkish Literature, 1918) founded the modern study of the subject, read this as the legacy of the Central Asian saint Aḥmad Yasawī (d. 1166) and his "saints of Khurasan".3 Later scholars, above all Ahmet T. Karamustafa and Ahmet Yaşar Ocak, have shown that the Yasawī link is largely a later construction, but nobody disputes the basic picture of a frontier Islam carried by holy men rather than by jurists.45

Three things, then, were missing from Anatolian Islam in 1200, and the next century supplied all three:

  • An institution. Lodges existed, but not orders with a founder, a rule and a succession that could outlive a single holy man.
  • A shared language of devotion. The court prayed and wrote in Persian; the pastures sang in Turkish; nothing bound the two.
  • A means of conversion. The madrasa trained judges for Muslims; it had no instrument for reaching the Christian villages or for disciplining the Turkmen.

The transmission: refugees from the Mongols

The family from Balkh

The transmission began as a flight. In the second decade of the thirteenth century the Khwarazmian empire, which ruled Khurasan and Transoxiana, collapsed before Chinggis Khan's armies; Bukhara and Samarkand fell in 1220, Balkh in 1220–21, Nishapur and Herat in 1221. Thousands of the learned left westward. Among them was Bahāʾ al-Dīn Walad, a preacher and jurist of Balkh, with his family. His departure is dated variously between c. 1212 and 1219, and the reason is debated: the hagiographers say he foresaw the Mongols; M. Nazif Şahinoğlu's entry in the Turkish İslâm Ansiklopedisi and Franklin Lewis both point to a quarrel with the Khwarazmshah's court and suggest he went first to Samarkand.67 The route is not in dispute: Baghdad, Mecca, Damascus, Malatya, Erzincan, Akşehir, then about seven years in Lārende (Karaman), and in 1228 an invitation from Kayqubād I to teach in a Konya madrasa. He died there on 23 February 1231.6

His son Jalāl al-Dīn Muḥammad, born on 30 September 1207 — at Balkh in the traditional account, at the small town of Vakhsh in Lewis's reconstruction — succeeded him as teacher.78 For thirteen years Jalāl al-Dīn was a learned jurist and preacher of a kind Konya already knew. Then, on 29 November 1244, a wandering dervish from Tabriz, Shams al-Dīn, arrived in the city, and the jurist became the poet Anatolia would know simply as Mevlânâ, "our master", and the world as Rūmī — "the man from Rum". Shams vanished in 1247. The Dīvān-i Shams and the six books of the Masnavī, some 25,000 couplets of Persian verse, were composed over the next quarter-century. Rūmī died on 17 December 1273.8

A wide interior view of a richly painted and gilded tomb chamber with calligraphic bands, hanging lamps and a stained-glass window; at the bottom a cenotaph under a gold-embroidered cover topped by a tall turbaned cap, beneath a blue plaque.
Rūmī's tomb chamber in Konya, the mother house of the Mevlevi order. The cenotaph, under a gold-embroidered cover and crowned with a dervish's felt cap, stands where Sultan Walad built up his father's grave into a shrine. The lodge was closed by law in 1925 and reopened as a museum in 1927.
Murat Özsoy 1958. Mevlâna Museum (tomb of Rūmī), Konya, photographed 2019. CC BY-SA 4.0 via Wikimedia Commons. · CC BY-SA 4.0

Rūmī's family was only the most famous of the arrivals. The atlas can name the principal carriers:

Arrival From In Anatolia What came with him
Najm al-Dīn Rāzī (d. 1256) Khwarazm and Rayy, fleeing the Mongols via Ardabil Kayseri, October 1221; Sivas, 1223 The Mirṣād al-ʿibād, a Persian manual of the Kubrawī Sufi path, dedicated to Kayqubād I
Bahāʾ al-Dīn Walad (d. 1231) Balkh or Vakhsh Konya, 1228 A preaching and teaching household; his son Jalāl al-Dīn
Shams al-Dīn of Tabriz (d. after 1247) Tabriz Konya, 29 November 1244 The wandering-dervish model that turned Rūmī into a poet
Baba Ilyās (d. 1240) Khurasan, of the Wafāʾī lineage Lodge at Çat near Amasya, under Kayqubād I Charismatic Turkmen leadership; the Babaʾī movement
Hacı Bektaş (d. c. 1270) Remembered as "Khurasani" Sulucakarahöyük, near Kırşehir The figure around whom the Bektashi order would gather
Akhī Evren (d. 1262) Khoy, Azerbaijan Kayseri and Kırşehir The akhī craft-brotherhood tradition

Najm al-Dīn Rāzī, fleeing the Mongol sack of his town, reached Kayseri in October 1221 and finished his Mirṣād al-ʿibād in Sivas in 1223, dedicating it to the sultan as a guide for kings as well as dervishes.910 The book is the clearest document of what the refugees were carrying: not a doctrine but a programme, the Sufi path laid out as stations and disciplines that a ruler should protect and endow.

The babas of the pastures

A second stream of Sufism reached Anatolia by a different road and spoke a different language. Turkmen tribesmen were pushed westward by the same Mongol advance, and with them came wandering holy men: Qalandars with shaved heads and eyebrows, Ḥaydarīs with iron rings through their bodies, and babas of established lineages such as the Wafāʾiyya, founded in Iraq by Abu'l-Wafāʾ (d. 1107). Karamustafa's God's Unruly Friends (1994) calls their practice "deviant renunciation": a deliberate breaking of social convention — nakedness, begging, the refusal of work and marriage — as a road to God.4 One of these men, Baba Ilyās, called Khurāsānī, founded a lodge at Çat near Amasya in the reign of Kayqubād I and drew a large following among the Turkmen. Ocak writes that "Baba Ilyās's person, already sanctified in his lifetime, gradually became the centre of a new syncretistic religious-mystical movement."5

The two streams met in the same towns and despised each other with some regularity. Aflākī's Manāqib al-ʿārifīn, the hagiography of Rūmī's family compiled in the first half of the fourteenth century, records the Mevlevis' contempt for the "Qalandars" and "Turks" of the pastures; the Turkmen babas, for their part, rose in arms in 1240 against the same Seljuk court that endowed Rūmī's madrasa.11

From circle to order: Sultan Walad

Rūmī did not found an order. He had a circle: disciples, a ritual of music and turning (samāʿ) that scandalised some jurists, and a successor he chose himself, Ḥusām al-Dīn Chalabī, who held the position until 1284. What turned the circle into an institution was Rūmī's son, Sultan Walad (1226–1312). Ş. Barihüda Tanrıkorur's entry on the order in the İslâm Ansiklopedisi sets out what he did: he made the succession hereditary in Rūmī's family, so that the head of the order (the Çelebi) would always be a descendant; he had the tomb in Konya built up into a shrine; he wrote the order's teaching into his own Persian mathnavīs and into some of the earliest Turkish Sufi verse; and he sent deputies to found branch houses in Amasya, Kırşehir, Erzincan and other towns.12 His son Ulu ʿĀrif Chalabī (d. 1320) travelled through the new Turkmen principalities enrolling their rulers. UNESCO's description of the Mevlevi order — "an ascetic Sufi order founded in 1273 in Konya, from where it gradually spread throughout the Ottoman Empire" — dates the order to Rūmī's death, which is the right date for its founding myth and the wrong one for its institutions.13

This is why the atlas anchors the record at c. 1300. In that generation a Khurasani household became a Turkish institution: the Mevlevi order had a founder's shrine, a hereditary chief in Konya, a ritual, a literature in Persian and Turkish, and branch lodges spread across Anatolia. The Ottoman beylik was founded in the same decade.

After Köse Dağ: Sufis under Mongol protection

The Mongols who had driven the refugees out of Khurasan followed them into Anatolia. On 26 June 1243 a Mongol army under Baiju destroyed the Seljuk army at Köse Dağ, east of Sivas, and the sultanate of Rum became a tributary of the Mongol empire and then of its Iranian successor, the Ilkhanate. For the next eighty years the real rulers of Anatolia were Mongol governors and the Persian ministers who managed the province for them. One of those ministers, Muʿīn al-Dīn Sulaymān, the Parvāna (d. 1277), was Rūmī's patron and one of the most generous builders of lodges and madrasas of the century; Aflākī's hagiography repeatedly shows him at Rūmī's sessions.11

A. C. S. Peacock's Islam, Literature and Society in Mongol Anatolia (2019) argues that this is the context the older nationalist histories left out: the period of Mongol overlordship, not the high Seljuk age, was when Anatolian Sufism grew most, because Mongol and Persian elites who did not share the Seljuk sultans' dynastic interests poured endowments into lodges as a way of building local support, and because Sufi masters offered a religious authority that did not depend on the weakened sultanate.10 The orders that took shape around 1300 were, in this sense, products of Mongol rule as much as of flight from it. The same generation saw the Seljuk sultanate dwindle to a title; the last sultan disappears from the record in the first decade of the fourteenth century, and power passed to the frontier lords.

Hacı Bektaş and the making of a patron saint

Of the historical Hacı Bektaş almost nothing is known. He seems to have been a disciple of Baba Ilyās, he settled at Sulucakarahöyük near Kırşehir, and he probably died around 1270–71.414 His brother Menteş joined the 1240 revolt and was killed; Hacı Bektaş himself stayed out of it.14 The figure everyone knows is the saint of the Vilāyetnāme, an anonymous hagiography of the late fifteenth century, which makes him a Khurasani prince sent to Anatolia by Aḥmad Yasawī himself — a direct succession, Ocak points out, from a master who had died some fifty years before he could have been born.14

The Bektashi order was assembled around this figure over two centuries. Irène Mélikoff's Hadji Bektach: un mythe et ses avatars (1998) traces the absorption into his name of Qalandar, Ḥaydarī, Abdal and Turkmen traditions.15 Its decisive organiser was Balım Sultan, appointed to the Hacıbektaş lodge by Bayezid II in 1501, who is credited with the order's celibate branch, its initiation ritual and its fixed structure; he died in 1516.16

The Naqshbandis come late

The third order named in the calendar arrived two centuries after the first two, and by a different route. The Naqshbandiyya, a Transoxianan order that insisted on strict observance of the law and a silent remembrance of God, reached Anatolia through one man: Molla ʿAbdullāh İlāhī of Simav, who went east to study in Samarkand under the great Naqshbandi master ʿUbaydullāh Aḥrār, came back to found a lodge in his home town, taught in the new Ottoman capital of Istanbul, and died at Yenice-i Vardar in Macedonia in 1491.17 Dina Le Gall's A Culture of Sufism (2005) shows how the order then spread through the Ottoman learned class, carried by Persian texts and by migrants from Bukhara and Herat.18 The sixteenth-century biographer Lāmiʿī, quoted in the İslâm Ansiklopedisi, put it in one line: "the fame of the Path of the Masters spread through the land of Rum."17

What changed and what was replaced

The lodge as frontier institution

The most consequential change was physical. Across Anatolia and then the Balkans the dervish lodge — zāviye in Turkish, tekke in its larger form — became the institution through which Muslims settled new land. Ömer Lütfi Barkan, using sixteenth-century Ottoman land and tax registers, argued in a famous 1942 article that the "colonising Turkish dervishes" were the advance guard of Ottoman settlement: a holy man and his followers were granted uncultivated land on a road or at a river crossing, built a lodge with a kitchen and guest rooms, fed travellers, cleared fields, and drew a village around them.19 The early Ottoman sultans endowed such lodges by the dozen, and Cemal Kafadar's Between Two Worlds (1995) places dervishes alongside frontier warriors as the makers of the first Ottoman state.20

What the lodge did, in practice, was a list of functions no other institution performed on the frontier:

  • Hospitality. A guaranteed meal and bed for travellers on roads where there were no inns.
  • Settlement. Endowed land drew cultivators, and a lodge village could become a town.
  • Conversion. Christians could visit a saint's tomb, receive a blessing and come back, long before they changed religion.
  • Arbitration. The baba settled disputes among Turkmen who did not go to the judge.
  • Memory. The founder's tomb became a shrine, and the shrine gave the place its name.

Vryonis is careful about the timing: "there is no way of ascertaining whether the dervish orders had begun to operate effectively and on a large scale in Asia Minor" before the Mongol period; "it is only in the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries that the conversionary activities of these orders become manifest in the sources."1 That is the transmission this record describes.

Akhīs, guilds and the urban lodge

In the towns the same model took a different form. The akhī brotherhoods — associations of young unmarried craftsmen organised around the ethic of futuwwa, chivalric generosity, which the caliph al-Nāṣir had reorganised in Baghdad between 1180 and 1225 — spread through Anatolia from the mid-thirteenth century; their remembered founder, Akhī Evren, came from Khoy and died in 1262.21 When Ibn Baṭṭūṭa crossed Anatolia in the early 1330s he found an akhī lodge in every town and was fed in most of them. "Nowhere in the world," he wrote, "will you find men so eager to welcome strangers, so prompt to serve food and to satisfy the wants of others, and so ready to suppress injustice and to kill [tyrannical] agents of police and the miscreants who join with them."22 In some towns between the Seljuk collapse and the Ottoman conquest, the akhīs were the government. The Ottoman craft guilds that replaced them kept their ceremonies of initiation into the nineteenth century.

A new language of devotion

The lodges also changed what language Anatolian Muslims prayed in. The Khurasani masters wrote in Persian, and the Mevlevi order remained a school of Persian for six centuries; the Masnavī was recited, commented and taught in Persian in every Mevlevi house from Konya to Cairo. But Sultan Walad had already written some of the earliest Turkish Sufi verse in Anatolia, scattered through his Persian works, so that his teaching could reach the Turkmen, and the generation after him produced a Turkish devotional poetry of its own.12

Its greatest figure was Yunus Emre (d. c. 1320), a poet of the Sakarya valley whom Köprülü made the centre of his 1918 study.3 Yunus wrote in the plain Turkish of the countryside, in syllabic folk metres rather than Persian quantitative ones, and his hymns — on divine love, death and the equality of believers — were sung in Bektashi, Mevlevi and Alevi gatherings alike. Through him and the poets who followed, the religion brought by the Persian-speaking refugees acquired a Turkish voice, and Turkish acquired a literature. The Alevi and Bektashi nefes hymns, the Mevlevi ilâhîs and much of the earliest Anatolian Turkish poetry descend from this moment. What was displaced, in turn, was the court's monopoly on literary culture: Persian remained the language of high learning, but the language of the lodge became Turkish, and with it the religious literature of the people who were not at court.

The Janissary hearth

The strangest change was military. The Janissaries — the yeni çeri, "new troops" — were the Ottoman sultans' standing infantry, recruited through the devşirme: a levy of Christian boys, mostly from Balkan and Anatolian villages, taken from their families, converted to Islam and trained as soldiers and administrators. The levy was practised under Mehmed I (r. 1413–1421) and regularised under Murad II; boys between eight and twenty were preferred, the levy was held every three, five or seven years as the corps needed, and the last levy is placed in 1751.23

These converts were given a saint. "The Janissaries, by long-standing tradition," Karamustafa writes, "paid allegiance to Haci Bektas, the patron saint of the Bektasi group."4 The corps was called the ocak, the hearth, of Hacı Bektaş; a Bektashi baba was attached to it, and its oaths and ceremonies were Bektashi. When the bond began is debated. Ocak dates it to the fifteenth century and its formalisation to Bayezid II's reign; A. Gül, in a 2022 study, argues that the link was a legend of the late sixteenth century that became an institution only in the early seventeenth.1624 Either way, the consequence is the same: the order that had gathered up the Turkmen dervish tradition became the religion of an army of converted Christian boys — and its fate became tied to theirs.

A watercolour of a moustached soldier in a pink kaftan and a tall white felt cap with a gilded front plate, carrying a matchlock on his shoulder with an axe and sabre at his belt, a lion lying at his feet; Italian inscriptions above.
A Janissary on campaign, painted c. 1577–80 by the Florentine court artist Jacopo Ligozzi. The corps that carried Hacı Bektaş as its patron saint was recruited through the levy of Christian boys; its tall white felt cap was said to recall the sleeve of the saint's cloak.
Jacopo Ligozzi. A Janissary "of War" with a Lion, c. 1577–80. The Metropolitan Museum of Art (1997.21). CC0 via Wikimedia Commons. · CC0

Sultans and dervishes

Each order found its place in the Ottoman state, and each place was different:

Order Social base Language Relation to the state
Mevlevi Urban, learned, courtly Persian and Ottoman Turkish Favoured; patronised by sultans, Selim III among its initiates
Bektashi Janissaries, Balkan and Anatolian villages Turkish Tied to the corps; suspected of heterodoxy; banned in 1826
Naqshbandi Ulema, officials, scholars Persian, Arabic and Turkish Orthodox, law-minded; inherited Bektashi lodges in 1826
Kızılbaş / Alevi (related) Turkmen tribes, eastern Anatolia Turkish Persecuted as Safavid partisans from 1511

The Mevlevis became the order of the Ottoman cultured class. Their lodges in Istanbul — Galata, Yenikapı, Kasımpaşa — were schools of music and Persian poetry, and Selim III (r. 1789–1807), himself a Mevlevi and a composer, restored the Galata lodge in 1791–92 under its sheikh, the poet Şeyh Galib. The ceremony of turning, the semā, became one of the defining forms of Ottoman art music.

An engraving of a tall hall with many windows and a hoop chandelier; four dervishes in tall caps and full skirts turn with outstretched arms while two bow to the floor, spectators watch from behind a balustrade, and a sheikh stands at the right.
The Mevlevi semā in an Istanbul lodge as a European visitor saw it: an engraving by William Hogarth for Aubry de La Mottraye's Travels, published in London in 1723–24. By then the ceremony was one of the sights of the Ottoman capital and a school of its art music.
William Hogarth. The Inside of a Mosque, the Dervishes Dancing (La Mottraye's Travels, vol. I, pl. 16), 1723–24. The Metropolitan Museum of Art (32.35(234)). CC0 via Wikimedia Commons. · CC0

What was displaced

The transmission also displaced. The first casualty was the Christian institutional landscape the dervishes settled among. The lodges did not destroy churches as a matter of policy, but they replaced them as the places where blessing, healing and hospitality were sought, and Vryonis documents how saints' shrines were taken over — Christian holy sites re-dedicated to Muslim saints, sometimes with the same story told under a new name.1 The second casualty was the free charismatic holy man. The orders absorbed the wandering Qalandars and Abdals, gave them rules and a hierarchy, and made those who would not submit into outlaws; Karamustafa traces how "deviant renunciation" was tamed into regular Sufi orders under Ottoman pressure in the sixteenth century.4 The third was the plurality of Turkmen religion itself, narrowed between an orthodox Sunni Sufism that the state endowed and a heterodox one it would increasingly treat as treason.

What the cost was

Malya, 1240

The first cost came within two decades. In 1239–40 the Turkmen following of Baba Ilyās rose against the Seljuk sultan Kaykhusraw II in the region of Kefersud and Malatya.5 The only near-contemporary narrative is hostile: Bar Hebraeus, the Syriac Christian chronicler, writing decades later, says a "Papa" (Baba) called himself the messenger of God, that his followers killed everyone who would not confess him a prophet, and that they routed the cavalry of Malatya.25 Baba Ilyās was captured and executed at Amasya — Bar Hebraeus says strangled by nobles. The rebels, now led by Baba Isḥāq, were met on the plain of Malya near Kırşehir by a Seljuk army that included about a thousand Frankish mercenary horsemen. Bar Hebraeus's account of the end reads:

"Then one thousand Frankish horsemen who were in the service of the Sultan became inflamed with anger … and they destroyed them all with the edge of the sword, and of them they left no creature, neither man nor woman, nor child, nor animal, with the breath of life therein."25

The numbers — sixty thousand Seljuk horsemen against six thousand rebels, in the same source — are not credible as counts, and "left no creature" is rhetoric. Ocak's summary is plainer: most of the Turkmen were put to the sword and the rest enslaved.5 The Babaʾī movement survived underground, and later Bektashi and Alevi tradition remembers its dead as its own.

Karaburun and Serres, 1416

The second cost came during the Ottoman civil war. Sheikh Bedreddin of Simavna, a jurist and Sufi who had served as chief military judge under the prince Musa, became the figurehead of a rising in 1416 led by two of his disciples: Börklüce Mustafa on the Karaburun peninsula opposite Chios, and Torlak Kemal near Manisa. The Byzantine historian Doukas reports that Börklüce taught "that anyone among the Turks who contended that the Christians are not God-fearing, is himself ungodly."26 Over six thousand of his followers defeated two provincial armies before the twelve-year-old prince Murad and the vizier Bayezid Pasha were sent against them.

Doukas describes what followed. The Ottoman army "mercilessly struck down everyone in sight, the old as well as infants, men, and women". Börklüce was taken to Ephesus: "Sitting him on a camel with his hands outstretched, affixed to planks by nails, he was paraded through the center of the city. Because his disciples refused to renounce their teacher's doctrine, they were all slaughtered before his eyes." Then Bayezid Pasha "traversed Asia and Lydia, putting to death all the Turkish monks whom he met on the way who were living in voluntary poverty."26 Bedreddin himself was captured and hanged at Serres after a jurist's ruling; Michel Balivet and most historians date the execution to 1416, while Bilal Dindar's İslâm Ansiklopedisi entry gives 1420.2728

The Kızılbaş registers, 1511–1514

The third and heaviest cost fell on the Turkmen heirs of the Babaʾī tradition. From the 1490s the Safavid order of Ardabil, led by the young Shah Ismāʿīl, recruited Anatolian Turkmen as its Kızılbaş, "red heads", for their twelve-gored red caps. The Ottoman state saw a fifth column. In 1511 the Kızılbaş rising of Şahkulu in the Teke region of southwestern Anatolia killed an Ottoman governor and defeated an imperial army before it was crushed. In 1512 Selim I deposed his father, and in 1513–14, before his campaign to Chaldiran, Kızılbaş were registered in the eastern provinces and killed or imprisoned. The court historian İdris Bitlisî reports that the names of forty thousand people were recorded and more than forty thousand killed — a single, round, panegyric figure that blames the killing on the greed of officials rather than the sultan, and that historians treat as a report, not a count.29

Ayfer Karakaya-Stump's The Kizilbash/Alevis in Ottoman Anatolia (2019) shows that the Kızılbaş grew out of the same dervish milieu — Wafāʾī lineages, Abdals, the Hacıbektaş lodge — that the Bektashi order had absorbed.30 The jurists divided. Abdurrahman Atçıl's study of the rulings of 1514 shows that Sarıgörez licensed the persecution of Kızılbaş everywhere, while Kemalpaşazade, usually remembered as the author of a fatwa for massacre, in fact prohibited persecuting the sultan's own Kızılbaş subjects; Ebussuud later urged deference and leniency.31 What followed was not one massacre but a status: for four centuries the Alevis of Anatolia were legally suspect, called heretics, and kept apart from the Sunni Sufism the state endowed.

The boys of the levy

The Bektashi bond with the Janissaries carries a cost of its own that is easy to overlook because it was not paid by Muslims. The corps the order served was filled, for three centuries, by the devşirme: Christian boys taken from their families in Balkan and Anatolian villages, marched to Istanbul, circumcised, converted and placed with Turkish families or in palace schools before entering the army.23 The Bektashi baba of the corps was their religious formation. The atlas's Balkan administration record discusses the levy at length; here it is enough to say that the order which carried the gentle hymns of the Turkmen pastures was, for its most powerful constituency, the religion given to children who had not chosen it.

How many boys were taken is not known with any precision; levies were irregular and the registers survive unevenly. The İslâm Ansiklopedisi records the training corps never exceeding ten thousand and a levy of about a thousand boys as late as the early eighteenth century; Gülay Yılmaz's study of the 1603–4 register from Bursa shows the levy in operation as a documented administrative process, with each boy listed by name, father and village.2332 The levy ended in the mid-eighteenth century; the corps it had filled ended in 1826.

The Auspicious Incident, 1826

The fourth cost was the destruction of the Janissary corps and, with it, the Bektashi order. On 15 June 1826 the Janissaries overturned their soup cauldrons in protest at Mahmud II's new army; the sultan unfurled the Prophet's banner, artillery shelled their barracks, and by noon on 17 June the executions were still going on. The official chronicler Esʿad Efendi gave about six thousand executed; the British ambassador Stratford Canning reported six thousand on 22 June and eight thousand on 25 June; a figure of thirty-three thousand was spread deliberately. Kemal Beydilli, in the İslâm Ansiklopedisi, treats all of them as "an indication of the deceptive effect of official propaganda that played with the numbers."33

On 8 July 1826 a council in the Bâbüssaâde mosque, chaired by the chief jurist with the sultan present, banned the Bektashi order. On 10 July three Bektashi notables — Kıncı Baba in Üsküdar, Ağasızâde Ahmed at Tophane and Salih Efendi at the Imperial Gate — were executed, and Ottoman archival files name two more, Esad Baba and Hüseyin Baba of Yedikule.34 Lodges built within the previous sixty years were demolished; older ones were turned into mosques and madrasas or handed to the Naqshbandi, Mevlevi and Rifāʿī orders, and a Naqshbandi sheikh from Kayseri was put in charge of Hacıbektaş itself. The head of the order, Hamdullah Çelebi, was tried at Kırşehir and exiled to Amasya, where — Fahri Maden's archival study shows — he died in 1846, not in 1836 as tradition held.3435 Ocak judges the repression narrower than its reputation: Mahmud II, he writes, "did not go beyond executing a few minor lodge sheikhs" and exiled the head of the order.16 The order survived underground and revived after 1839.

1925 and after

The fifth cost was the closure of all of them. Law 677 of the Turkish Republic, passed on 30 November 1925 and published on 13 December, declared that "all tekkes and zaviyes … are entirely closed", abolished the titles of sheikh, dervish, dede, çelebi and baba, and punished anyone who continued them with not less than three months' prison and a fine of not less than fifty lira.36 The Mevlevi tomb in Konya was reopened in 1927 as a museum; the Bektashi leadership left for Albania, and the order's world headquarters was established in Tirana in 1930. The law is still in force.

  • 1826: the Bektashi order banned; Janissary corps destroyed; at least three, possibly five, Bektashi leaders executed.
  • 1925: every Sufi lodge in the Turkish Republic closed by law.
  • 1949: penalties for leaders raised to six months' prison and a year's internal exile.
  • 1978: Maraş, 19–26 December — some 105–111 people killed, most of them Alevis.
  • 1980: Çorum, May–July — as many as 57 killed.
  • 1993: Sivas, 2 July — 35 killed at an Alevi festival.

Sivas, 1993

On 2 July 1993 a crowd set fire to the Madımak Hotel in Sivas, where artists and writers had gathered for a festival in honour of Pir Sultan Abdal, the sixteenth-century Alevi poet executed by an Ottoman governor. Thirty-three intellectuals and musicians and two hotel workers died; two of the attackers also died. Whether the target was the writer Aziz Nesin, who had published passages of Salman Rushdie's novel and escaped by a fire ladder, or the Alevis themselves, is still argued; the dead are remembered by Alevis as martyrs of a line that runs back through the Kızılbaş to the Babaʾīs.

Weighing the bill

The transmission itself — refugees carrying an institution — was peaceful, and much of what it built was humane: free meals for travellers, the poetry of Rūmī, a music still performed. The cost lies in what the state made of the orders. The Seljuk court massacred the first Turkmen movement; the Ottoman state crushed the second, persecuted the third for four centuries, tied the Bektashis to an army recruited by taking Christian children, and destroyed both in 1826; the Republic closed every lodge in 1925. UNESCO inscribed the Mevlevi semā on its Representative List of intangible heritage in 2008 and the Alevi-Bektashi semah in 2010.1337 Both ceremonies are protected as heritage in a country where the lodges that performed them remain closed by law.

What followed

Where this lives today

The Mevlevi semā ceremony, on UNESCO's intangible heritage list since 2008 The Alevi cem and semah, the communal worship of Turkey's Alevis The Bektashi world headquarters in Tirana, Albania, since 1930 The Mevlâna Museum in Konya, one of Turkey's most visited sites Yunus Emre's Turkish hymns and the Anatolian devotional poetry they began Naqshbandi networks in modern Turkish religious and political life

References

  1. Vryonis, Speros, Jr. The Decline of Medieval Hellenism in Asia Minor and the Process of Islamization from the Eleventh through the Fifteenth Century. Berkeley, Los Angeles and London: University of California Press, 1971. en
  2. Cahen, Claude. La Turquie pré-ottomane. Varia Turcica 7. Istanbul and Paris: Institut français d'études anatoliennes, 1988. (Earlier English version: Pre-Ottoman Turkey, trans. J. Jones-Williams. New York: Taplinger, 1968.) fr
  3. Köprülü, Mehmed Fuad. Türk Edebiyatında İlk Mutasavvıflar. Istanbul, 1918. English translation: Early Mystics in Turkish Literature, trans. and ed. Gary Leiser and Robert Dankoff. London and New York: Routledge, 2006. tr
  4. Karamustafa, Ahmet T. God's Unruly Friends: Dervish Groups in the Islamic Later Middle Period, 1200–1550. Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press, 1994. en
  5. Ocak, Ahmet Yaşar. "Babaîlik." In TDV İslâm Ansiklopedisi, vol. 4. Istanbul: Türkiye Diyanet Vakfı, 1991. See also his Babaîler İsyanı: Alevîliğin Tarihsel Altyapısı. Istanbul, 1996. tr
  6. Şahinoğlu, M. Nazif. "Bahâeddin Veled." In TDV İslâm Ansiklopedisi, vol. 4. Istanbul: Türkiye Diyanet Vakfı, 1991. tr
  7. Lewis, Franklin D. Rumi: Past and Present, East and West. The Life, Teaching and Poetry of Jalâl al-Din Rumi. Oxford: Oneworld, 2000. en
  8. Öngören, Reşat. "Mevlânâ Celâleddîn-i Rûmî." In TDV İslâm Ansiklopedisi, vol. 29. Ankara: Türkiye Diyanet Vakfı, 2004. tr
  9. Najm al-Dīn Rāzī. The Path of God's Bondsmen from Origin to Return (Merṣād al-ʿebād men al-mabdaʾ elā'l-maʿād), trans. Hamid Algar. Delmar, NY: Caravan Books, 1982. Completed in Sivas, 1223. en primary
  10. Peacock, A. C. S. Islam, Literature and Society in Mongol Anatolia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2019. en
  11. Aflākī, Shams al-Dīn Aḥmad. The Feats of the Knowers of God (Manāqeb al-ʿārefīn), trans. John O'Kane. Leiden: Brill, 2002. en primary
  12. Tanrıkorur, Şefik Barihüda. "Mevleviyye." In TDV İslâm Ansiklopedisi, vol. 29. Ankara: Türkiye Diyanet Vakfı, 2004. tr
  13. UNESCO Intangible Cultural Heritage. "Mevlevi Sema ceremony." Proclaimed 2005; inscribed on the Representative List of the Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity, 2008 (3.COM). en
  14. Ocak, Ahmet Yaşar. "Hacı Bektâş-ı Velî." In TDV İslâm Ansiklopedisi, vol. 14. Istanbul: Türkiye Diyanet Vakfı, 1996. tr
  15. Mélikoff, Irène. Hadji Bektach: un mythe et ses avatars. Genèse et évolution du soufisme populaire en Turquie. Islamic History and Civilization 20. Leiden: Brill, 1998. fr
  16. Ocak, Ahmet Yaşar. "Bektaşîlik." In TDV İslâm Ansiklopedisi, vol. 5. Istanbul: Türkiye Diyanet Vakfı, 1992. tr
  17. Kara, Mustafa, and Hamid Algar. "Abdullah-ı İlâhî." In TDV İslâm Ansiklopedisi, vol. 1. Istanbul: Türkiye Diyanet Vakfı, 1988. tr
  18. Le Gall, Dina. A Culture of Sufism: Naqshbandīs in the Ottoman World, 1450–1700. Albany: State University of New York Press, 2005. en
  19. Barkan, Ömer Lütfi. "Osmanlı İmparatorluğunda Bir İskân ve Kolonizasyon Metodu Olarak Vakıflar ve Temlikler I: İstilâ Devirlerinin Kolonizatör Türk Dervişleri ve Zâviyeler." Vakıflar Dergisi 2 (1942): 279–353. tr
  20. Kafadar, Cemal. Between Two Worlds: The Construction of the Ottoman State. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1995. en
  21. Kazıcı, Ziya. "Ahîlik." In TDV İslâm Ansiklopedisi, vol. 1. Istanbul: Türkiye Diyanet Vakfı, 1988. tr
  22. Ibn Baṭṭūṭa. Travels in Asia and Africa, 1325–1354, trans. and ed. H. A. R. Gibb. The Broadway Travellers. London: Routledge, 1929. en primary
  23. Özcan, Abdülkadir. "Devşirme." In TDV İslâm Ansiklopedisi, vol. 9. Istanbul: Türkiye Diyanet Vakfı, 1994. tr
  24. Gül, A. "The Power of a Legend: Examining the Historical Development of the Relationship between the Janissaries and Bektashi." Tarih Dergisi – Turkish Journal of History (2022). tr
  25. Bar Hebraeus. The Chronography of Gregory Abû'l Faraj … commonly known as Bar Hebraeus, trans. E. A. Wallis Budge. London: Oxford University Press, 1932. en primary
  26. Doukas. Decline and Fall of Byzantium to the Ottoman Turks: An Annotated Translation of "Historia Turco-Byzantina", trans. Harry J. Magoulias. Detroit: Wayne State University Press, 1975, 119–121. en primary
  27. Balivet, Michel. Islam mystique et révolution armée dans les Balkans ottomans: vie du Cheikh Bedreddîn, le « Hallâj des Turcs » (1358/59–1416). Cahiers du Bosphore 12. Istanbul: Isis, 1995. fr
  28. Dindar, Bilal. "Bedreddin Simâvî." In TDV İslâm Ansiklopedisi, vol. 5. Istanbul: Türkiye Diyanet Vakfı, 1992. tr
  29. Tekindağ, M. C. Şehabeddin. "Yeni Kaynak ve Vesikaların Işığı Altında Yavuz Sultan Selim'in İran Seferi." Tarih Dergisi 17/22 (1967). Discusses the figure of forty thousand given by İdris Bitlisî's Selimşâhnâme. tr
  30. Karakaya-Stump, Ayfer. The Kizilbash/Alevis in Ottoman Anatolia: Sufism, Politics and Community. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 2019. en
  31. Atçıl, Abdurrahman. "The Safavid Threat and Juristic Authority in the Ottoman Empire during the 16th Century." International Journal of Middle East Studies 49, no. 2 (2017): 295–314. en
  32. Yılmaz, Gülay. "The Devshirme System and the Levied Children of Bursa in 1603–4." Belleten 79, no. 286 (2015): 901–930. tr
  33. Beydilli, Kemal. "Vak'a-i Hayriyye." In TDV İslâm Ansiklopedisi, vol. 42. Istanbul: Türkiye Diyanet Vakfı, 2012. tr
  34. Erduğan, Serkan. "Bektaşi Tekkelerinin Kapatılması ve Hamdullah Efendi." Alevilik-Bektaşilik Araştırmaları Dergisi 17 (2018): 193ff. Draws on Esʿad Efendi, Üss-i Zafer (1828), ed. Mehmet Arslan (Istanbul: Kitabevi, 2005), and Ottoman archival files (BOA HAT 290/17351, 293/17438). tr
  35. Maden, Fahri. Bektaşî Tekkelerinin Kapatılması (1826) ve Bektaşîliğin Yasaklı Yılları. Ankara: Türk Tarih Kurumu, 2013. tr
  36. Tekke ve Zaviyelerle Türbelerin Seddine ve Türbedarlıklar ile Bir Takım Unvanların Men ve İlgasına Dair Kanun (Law no. 677). Adopted 30 November 1925; Resmî Gazete no. 243, 13 December 1925; Düstur, Tertip 3, vol. 7, 113. tr primary
  37. UNESCO Intangible Cultural Heritage. "Semah, Alevi-Bektaşi ritual." Inscribed on the Representative List of the Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity, 2010. en

Further reading

Cite this article
OsakaWire Atlas. 2026. "Khurasani Sufis remake Anatolian Islam (c. 1300) — and who paid" [Hidden Threads record]. https://osakawire.com/en/atlas/sufi_orders_to_anatolia_1300/