The pictorial histories of the Mexica and their neighbours burned or withdrawn under Itzcoatl (r. 1427–1440) so that a single official past joined to Tollan could replace them; thousands killed in state sacrifice by the dynasty that ruled through that claim, with 603 skulls, women and children among them, identified at Tenochtitlan's Huei Tzompantli by 2020; the Quetzalcoatl legend retold after 1521 to make the conquered complicit in their conquest; at least 3,000 and perhaps 20,000 killed at Cholula, Quetzalcoatl's pilgrimage city, on 18 October 1519, with no one convicted; and the Maya books burned at Maní in 1562 on the grounds the Mexica lords had already used.
CONNECTIONS · 700–1521 · RELIGION · From Toltec (Tula) → Mexica (Aztec)

The Toltec past the Mexica claimed (c. 1430) — and the books burned

Between about 700 and 1150 CE a cult of the Feathered Serpent linked shrine cities from Chichén Itzá to Tula. When Tula lay in ruins, the Mexica of Tenochtitlan, latecomers to the Basin of Mexico with no lineage of their own, made themselves its heirs: a king with a Culhua mother and Toltec blood, Toltec benches and chacmools copied in their sacred precinct, and two high priests who bore Quetzalcoatl's name. Under Itzcoatl the rulers burned the older histories. After 1521 the Quetzalcoatl legend was retold as a prophecy of their defeat.

In the 1370s the Mexica of Tenochtitlan, latecomers to the Basin of Mexico, chose as their first king Acamapichtli, whose Culhua mother gave the new dynasty a claim to the blood of Tollan, the ruined Toltec city seventy kilometres to the north-west. Over the next century they copied Tula's chacmools and warrior processions in their own sacred precinct, named their two highest priests after Quetzalcoatl, the Feathered Serpent, and credited the Toltecs with the calendar, the arts and wisdom itself, though all were far older than Tula. Under Itzcoatl, around the 1430s, the Mexica lords burned the older pictorial histories and replaced them with an official past. The empire that followed justified tribute and sacrifice through that inheritance. After 1521 the conquerors retold its central legend as a prophecy of the Mexica defeat.

Four tall stone warrior statues with feathered headdresses and breastplates stand with square pillars and carved column drums on a flat pyramid top under a clear blue sky.
The Atlantean columns on the summit of Pyramid B (the Temple of Tlahuizcalpantecuhtli) at Tula, Hidalgo, carved c. 900–1150 CE. Each 4.6-metre basalt warrior wears a feathered headdress and a butterfly pectoral and once supported the temple roof. The site is administered by Mexico's Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia (INAH).
Arian Zwegers. Atlantean columns on Pyramid B, Tula, Hidalgo, c. 900–1150 CE (photographed 2015). Zona Arqueológica de Tula, INAH. CC BY 2.0 via Wikimedia Commons. · CC BY 2.0

Before: a people who arrived without a past

In the thirteenth century a small Nahuatl-speaking people walked into the Basin of Mexico from the north and found every piece of good land already claimed. They called themselves Mexica. Their own later histories said they had left a place called Aztlan, wandered for generations behind a tribal god named Huitzilopochtli, and arrived in a valley that was full of cities older and stronger than they were 12. Around Lake Texcoco stood Azcapotzalco, the seat of the Tepanecs; Culhuacan, on the southern shore; Texcoco on the east; and a dozen lesser towns, each with a ruling house, a temple, a market and a claim to the land it farmed. The Mexica had none of those things. They hired themselves out as mercenaries, settled for a time on the hill of Chapultepec, were driven off it, and served the lords of Culhuacan as dependants before they were driven off again 1.

By tradition they founded their own town in 1325, on a marshy island in the western part of the lake that nobody else wanted 2. The place was named Tenochtitlan. For most of the following century it was a tributary of the Tepanec king at Azcapotzalco, paying in lake produce and military service. Camilla Townsend, whose history of the Mexica is built on the Nahuatl-language annals that indigenous writers kept after the conquest, describes a people who were for generations the newcomers, the poor relations and the hired soldiers of the basin 1. The Mexica of 1350 were not an empire. They were a town of fishermen, reed-cutters and warriors living on a swamp under a stronger neighbour's protection. The island had little farmland; its people built raised garden plots in the shallows, traded fish, waterfowl and reeds in the lakeshore markets for maize and stone, and fought in the Tepanec king's wars for a share of the spoils 12. Even their sister town on the same island, Tlatelolco, had its own ruler and its own patron among the Tepanecs. Nothing in the town's circumstances suggested that within a century it would rule much of Mesoamerica.

What the latecomers lacked

What the Mexica lacked, more than land, was standing. In the Nahua world a ruling house rested on descent, and descent was a matter of record: the town histories, painted on screenfold books of bark paper and deer hide, set out who had come from where, which lineage had founded which town, and which families held the right to rule. Susan Gillespie's study of the Mexica dynastic histories reads them as constructions, built and rebuilt to answer political needs 3. In the fourteenth century the Mexica needed one badly. Their neighbours could point to founders, to ancient alliances, to the ruins of older cities in their own territory. The Mexica could point to a migration from a place nobody else had seen. Gillespie's argument is that the histories which survive were shaped, at several stages, to make that weakness disappear, and that the Mexica past we read is in large part a product of the needs of later Mexica kings and of the colonial writers who recorded them 3. The shape of those needs is visible in what the established houses had and the Mexica did not.

The basin's established houses had, between them, the categories the Mexica would spend the next century acquiring:

  • A founding lineage recognised by other ruling houses, which made marriage alliances and treaties possible.
  • A recorded history in the painted books, kept by trained painter-scribes and consulted by rulers.
  • A claim on an older civilisation. Culhuacan in particular was held to descend from the Toltecs, the people of the ruined city of Tollan to the north-west.
  • Recognised temples and priesthoods tied to gods the whole basin acknowledged, not only to a tribal patron.
  • Land and tributaries of their own.

The Mexica had a god, Huitzilopochtli, a fighting reputation and an island. Their first task as a polity was to obtain the rest, and the item that made the others possible was the third: a claim on the civilisation that had come before. In the basin of the fourteenth century that civilisation had a name, Tollan, and a people, the Toltecs, whose city lay in ruins some seventy kilometres to the north-west 12.

An inheritance already two thousand years old

What they would claim was older than any of the cities they envied. By the time the Mexica arrived, the main elements of Mesoamerican religion had been in place for millennia, carried from one civilisation to the next. The 260-day ritual count, which the Nahua called the tonalpohualli and the Maya the tzolk'in, is the oldest of them. Ivan Šprajc, Takeshi Inomata and Anthony Aveni, measuring the orientations of early ceremonial complexes in the Olmec and Maya regions, found that complexes "built between 1100 and 750 BCE, in particular, represent the earliest evidence of the use of the 260-day calendar, centuries earlier than its previously known use in textual records" 5. The earliest securely dated written day sign, "7 Deer", was painted on a wall at San Bartolo in the Guatemalan lowlands between 300 and 200 BCE; as David Stuart and his co-authors write, it "represents a day in the 260-day divinatory calendar used throughout Mesoamerica and among indigenous Maya communities today" 6. The rubber-ball game played in walled courts is almost as old, and by the first millennium CE was played from Honduras to the deserts of the north 7.

The god the Mexica would most want to inherit had a long history too. At Teotihuacan, the great city north-east of the lake, a pyramid faced with carved heads of a feathered serpent was built around 200 CE, and beneath and around it Saburo Sugiyama's excavations found the remains of well over a hundred people killed and buried as dedicatory offerings, many of them armed as soldiers 4. The Feathered Serpent, in other words, was associated with rulership, war and sacrifice a thousand years before Tenochtitlan existed. Teotihuacan itself had been in ruins since the sixth century; the names its pyramids carry today are Nahuatl names, given by later peoples who knew the city only as a ruin. Between its fall and the rise of the Mexica, the serpent's cult passed through a further set of cities, and it was one of those, Tollan, that the Mexica would choose as their ancestor.

The transmission: how Tollan became an inheritance

The usual story of the Toltecs, as it was told for most of the twentieth century, runs in a straight line. A warrior people from Tula in central Mexico conquered the Maya city of Chichén Itzá in Yucatán in the tenth century, brought with them their god Quetzalcoatl, whom the Maya called Kukulkan, and imposed their architecture of colonnades and serpent columns on a Maya city; the Mexica, centuries later, inherited Tula's mantle. The classic statement of that model is Alfred Tozzer's two-volume study of Chichén Itzá and its sacred cenote, published by Harvard's Peabody Museum in 1957 10. The similarities that drove it are real. The Temple of the Warriors at Chichén and Pyramid B at Tula share a plan, a colonnaded hall in front of a stepped platform, serpent columns, carved processions of warriors and reclining stone figures, the chacmools, that hold a vessel on the belly.

A stepped stone temple pyramid with a central stairway and serpent-head sculptures at the top rises behind rows of weathered square stone pillars on a raised platform.
The Temple of the Warriors at Chichén Itzá, Yucatán, built c. 900–1100 CE, fronted by its colonnade of square warrior-carved pillars. Its plan, colonnaded hall and feathered-serpent columns closely parallel Pyramid B at Tula, the strongest architectural evidence for the Tula–Chichén Itzá connection. The site is administered by INAH and is a UNESCO World Heritage Site.
Vlad Podvorny. Temple of the Warriors, Chichén Itzá, c. 900–1100 CE (photographed 2021). Zona Arqueológica de Chichén Itzá, INAH. CC0 via Wikimedia Commons. · CC0

A shrine network, not a conquest

The straight line has not survived. In 1998 William Ringle, Tomás Gallareta Negrón and George Bey argued in Ancient Mesoamerica that the construction of Chichén Itzá "dates primarily to the Late Classic period, ca. a.d. 700–1000, rather than the Early Postclassic", which put most of it earlier than the Tula it was supposed to copy, and that "what is usually identified as Toltec imagery in fact dates to an earlier Epiclassic horizon" 8. Their alternative is a network: a cult of the Feathered Serpent that spread in the centuries after Teotihuacan's fall across political and linguistic boundaries, with shrine centres that drew pilgrims and shared a style. Chichén was its eastern node. Susan Gillespie, in the Dumbarton Oaks volume Twin Tollans that brought seventeen specialists together on the question, traced how the conquest model itself had been built, calling it "the development of an archaeological myth" 911. George Bey and William Ringle's chapter in the same volume examined the timing of the Tula–Chichén exchange from the bottom up, through ceramics and settlement, rather than from the monuments down 36.

The principal centres of the network, as Ringle and his colleagues identified them, were 8:

Centre Region Feathered Serpent evidence
Chichén Itzá Northern Maya lowlands, Yucatán Serpent columns, Temple of the Warriors, the cult of Kukulkan
Xochicalco Western Morelos Pyramid of the Feathered Serpent with carved serpent friezes
Cacaxtla Tlaxcala Murals combining Maya and central Mexican imagery
El Tajín Gulf Coast, Veracruz Ball courts and reliefs in the shared Epiclassic idiom
Cholula Puebla The great pyramid and the principal pilgrimage shrine of Quetzalcoatl
Tula Hidalgo, north-west of the basin Pyramid B, Atlantean columns, chacmools, colonnaded halls

Alfredo López Austin and Leonardo López Luján, in Mito y realidad de Zuyuá, read the same network as a political order: a system of Feathered Serpent kingship, which later Maya and Nahua texts associated with a mythical place of origin called Zuyuá, that allowed rulers of different ethnicities to legitimise themselves through a shared god and shared rites of investiture 19. In this reading the "Toltec" style is not the badge of one conquering people. It is the visual language of an international religion, and Tula was one of its capitals among several.

Tula at its height, and its end

Tula was nonetheless a large city. Dan Healan, Robert Cobean and Robert Bowsher, revising the site's chronology in 2021 on the basis of sixty-eight radiocarbon and seven archaeomagnetic dates, estimate that the Tollan-phase city covered some sixteen square kilometres 13. Ancient Tollan, the synthesis by Alba Guadalupe Mastache, Cobean and Healan, places its height in the Early Postclassic, roughly 900 to 1150 CE, around the ceremonial precinct of Tula Grande with its pyramids, ball courts, colonnaded halls and the four basalt warrior columns that once held up the roof of Pyramid B's temple 12. In Cobean and Mastache's account in Arqueología Mexicana, Tula of the tenth and eleventh centuries was "una gran ciudad de casi 15 km²", the historical Tollan of the chronicles 14.

The end came in the mid-twelfth century. "An estimated end date of a.d. 1150 for the Tollan phase was originally proposed by Cobean (1978)," Healan and his colleagues write, "and this date continues to be supported by recent chronometric and other data" 13. Archaeomagnetic dates on burned stucco from the building known as the Palacio Quemado, the Burned Palace, cluster around 1140 and 1175, and tree-ring evidence records a drought between 1149 and 1167 13. Older accounts blamed invading northern peoples for the burning. Healan's team find "no evidence that links the burning of Tula Grande to Aztec II" peoples, the ancestors of the basin's later Nahua population; the ceremonial centre "appear[s] to have already been abandoned and in ruins prior to the arrival of Aztec II peoples" 13.

Tula's own beginnings complicate the debate over who copied whom. Before the Tollan-phase city, an earlier centre now called Tula Chico occupied a hill to the north-east of Tula Grande, and Healan, Cobean and Bowsher note that reliefs from Tula Chico already show elements of the "Toltec" style, which bears on "the ongoing debate over the primacy of the Toltec style at Tula versus Chichén Itzá" 13. The likeliest reading of the evidence now is the one Ringle and his colleagues proposed: a style and a cult that grew up across several centres at once, exchanged by pilgrims, traders and rulers over two or three centuries, rather than one city exporting itself to another 836.

That matters for this record. The Mexica did not conquer Tula. They never met a living Toltec. What they inherited was a ruin and a reputation, and they assembled the rest.

Blood from Culhuacan

The first piece was a bloodline. Culhuacan, the town on the southern shore where the Mexica had once served as dependants, claimed descent from Tollan's rulers. When the Mexica of Tenochtitlan chose their first tlatoani, their first king, in the 1370s, they chose Acamapichtli, whose father was Mexica and whose mother was Culhua 13. Through her, the new dynasty could claim Toltec blood. Leonardo López Luján, who has directed the excavations around the Templo Mayor for decades, puts the consequence directly: "for the Mexica, the legitimacy of power was based on two beliefs: that their ruling lineage was descended from the god Quetzalcoatl and that it was linked to the ancient Tula through the blood ties of Acamapichtli, the founding king of the dynasty of Tenochtitlan" 16.

The story the Mexica told about Tollan's last king supplied the other half of the claim. The Annals of Cuauhtitlan, a Nahuatl chronicle preserved in the Codex Chimalpopoca and translated by John Bierhorst, tell of Topiltzin Quetzalcoatl, priest-king of Tollan, who was tricked into disgrace by sorcerers, abandoned his city and departed eastward to Tlillan Tlapallan, the land of the black and the red, in a year 1 Reed 15. The figure fuses a man and a god: a ruler who bore the Feathered Serpent's name, governed the archetypal city and left it. Michel Graulich, in Quetzalcóatl y el espejismo de Tollan, argued that much of this Tollan was a mirage, a mythic model projected onto the past rather than a remembered city 24. Whatever its historical core, it gave the Mexica a lineage that ran from Acamapichtli through Culhuacan to Quetzalcoatl himself.

Digging up Tollan

The second piece was material. From about 1350, Late Aztec people reoccupied the area around Tula's ruins, and they did more than farm it. Healan, Cobean and Bowsher describe a "preoccupation with Tula's ruins that parallels similar evidence from the Templo Mayor excavations suggesting it was indeed the place the Aztecs called Tollan" 13. The Late Aztec settlers dug into the old buildings, and Toltec objects travelled to Tenochtitlan. López Luján and López Austin, in a paper published in Spanish in Estudios de Cultura Náhuatl and in English in the Dumbarton Oaks volume The Art of Urbanism, call the result "a sort of neo-toltecism": at Tenochtitlan the Mexica copied Tula's chacmools, Atlantean figures, standard-bearers and processional friezes, and placed them at the heart of their own sacred precinct 1718. Their Spanish title states the two-way traffic exactly: "the Mexica in Tula and Tula in Mexico-Tenochtitlan". At its centre, they argue, stood "la díada Tollan-Quetzalcóatl", the pairing of a city and a god 18.

A reclining stone figure with traces of red, blue and white paint, knees drawn up and holding a round vessel on its stomach, lies on a grey stucco floor.
A polychrome chacmool still in situ before the Tlaloc shrine of an early building phase (Phase II, c. 1390 CE) of the Templo Mayor in Tenochtitlan, Mexico City. The reclining figure holding a vessel on its belly is a sculptural type first seen at Tula and Chichén Itzá, adopted by the Mexica as part of their claimed Toltec inheritance. The site is administered by INAH's Museo del Templo Mayor.
Luis Alvaz. Chacmool, Templo Mayor (Phase II), Tenochtitlan, c. 1390 CE (photographed 2003). Museo del Templo Mayor, INAH. CC BY-SA 4.0 via Wikimedia Commons. · CC BY-SA 4.0

The chacmool still lying in front of the Tlaloc shrine of the Templo Mayor's second building phase, painted in red, blue and white, is the most visible survivor of that programme. It is a sculptural type first seen in the Epiclassic network, reproduced in a city founded two centuries after Tula fell, by a people who had never been part of the network that made it.

What changed and what was replaced

By the 1420s the Mexica had a royal house with Toltec blood and a growing collection of Toltec forms. What turned these into an imperial ideology was war. In 1428 Tenochtitlan, allied with Texcoco and the Tepanec town of Tlacopan, overthrew Azcapotzalco, and the three cities became the core of the tribute empire later called Aztec 12. The Mexica ruler of the victory was Itzcoatl, who reigned from 1427 to 1440. Over the next ninety years the empire extended its tribute collection from the Gulf Coast to the Pacific. The Toltec claim moved from a family matter to a statement about who had the right to rule Mesoamerica.

The histories burned under Itzcoatl

The most consequential change was made with fire. Among the material that Bernardino de Sahagún's Nahua collaborators assembled in the sixteenth century is a short passage in Book 10 of the Florentine Codex, in the chapter on the peoples of New Spain. In the Nahuatl it reads: "Ca mopiaia in jtoloca, ca iquac tlatlac in tlatocat Itzcooatl, in mexico" 2023. Clementina Battcock's Spanish translation of the passage continues the sense: "Porque se guardaba la historia; pero ardió cuando gobernaba Itzcóatl en México. Se hizo concierto entre los señores mexicas. Dijeron: 'No es conveniente que todo mundo conozca la tinta negra, los colores [...] porque se inventaron muchas mentiras'" 23. In English: the history had been kept, but it burned when Itzcoatl ruled in Mexico; the Mexica lords agreed that it was not fitting for everyone to know the black ink and the colours, because many lies had been invented. Sahagún's own Spanish column says the pictures were burned because the lords "acordaron y mandaron que se quemasen todas, porque no viniesen a manos del vulgo y viniesen en menosprecio" 22.

Battcock's study of the passage, the most complete survey of its historiography, sets out the principal readings 23:

  • Miguel León-Portilla read the burning as the imposition of an official version of Mexica history, and named Itzcoatl's adviser Tlacaelel as its instigator.
  • Alfredo López Austin read it as an order given by Itzcoatl in his role as oracle of Huitzilopochtli, destroying an archive that had passed between capitals as legitimate inheritance or war booty.
  • Rudolf van Zantwijk dated the censorship to 1433 and attributed it jointly to Itzcoatl and Tlacaelel.
  • Michel Graulich argued that the Tenochca strove to erase the Toltecs from memory and put Huitzilopochtli in Quetzalcoatl's place.
  • Federico Navarrete held that the burning was partial, and that book-burning in Mesoamerica was not a Spanish invention.

Battcock adds a philological caution: the Nahuatl verb can carry the sense of hiding as well as burning 23. Even on the gentlest reading, the rulers of a newly victorious city decided which version of the past the population could see, and the books that told the older version were put out of reach.

The burning and the Toltec claim belong to the same programme. What replaced the old histories was the account later preserved in the Mexica annals: a migration from Aztlan guided by Huitzilopochtli, a destined founding at Tenochtitlan, and a royal line joined to Tollan through Culhuacan 13. A people who had arrived without a past now had an official one, and the documents that could contradict it were gone.

Huitzilopochtli in Quetzalcoatl's place

The religious change was a merger, and it was uneven. The Templo Mayor of Tenochtitlan, rebuilt and enlarged in seven major phases 2, carried twin shrines at its summit: one to Huitzilopochtli, the Mexica's own war god, and one to Tlaloc, the ancient rain god of the whole region. Quetzalcoatl did not get one of the two summit shrines. He was honoured in the precinct with a circular temple of his own aspect as Ehecatl, the wind 30, and his name was given to the highest offices of the priesthood. Sahagún's account of the priests in the appendix to Book 3 of the Florentine Codex records that there were two Quetzalcoatl, the paired high priests titled Quetzalcoatl Totec tlamacazqui and Quetzalcoatl Tlaloc tlamacazqui, one serving Huitzilopochtli and the other Tlaloc 25.

The arrangement is exact. The Toltec god became a title, held by the men who served the Mexica god and the old rain god at the top of the pyramid. Graulich's argument that the Tenochca put Huitzilopochtli in Quetzalcoatl's place reads this arrangement as a displacement 2324. López Austin and López Luján's reading of the Feathered Serpent as the god of legitimate kingship explains why the name had to be kept: the god who conferred the right to rule could not be discarded by rulers who needed that right 1819.

A codex page with a green-plumed serpent devouring a human figure at lower left, a grid of painted day-sign and deity heads with dot numerals above and right, and handwritten Spanish notes.
Quetzalcoatl as a feathered serpent swallowing a man, beside a thirteen-day period of the 260-day ritual calendar (tonalpohualli), from the Codex Telleriano-Remensis. The manuscript was painted in Mexico c. 1550s–1560s and is held by the Bibliothèque nationale de France (Mexicain 385); this image is from the 1899 Loubat facsimile. The Spanish gloss names the serpent 'quetzalcoatle'.
Unknown Nahua painter. Codex Telleriano-Remensis, Quetzalcoatl as feathered serpent, c. 1550s–1560s (Loubat facsimile, 1899). Bibliothèque nationale de France. Public domain via Wikimedia Commons. · Public domain

A Toltec stage for kings: the House of Eagles

The clearest material statement of the claim stands just north of the Templo Mayor. The House of Eagles, as López Luján describes it, was "built and enlarged three times between 1430 and 1502 AD" and is known "for its rich neo-Toltec ornamentation, inspired by a style that was fashionable four centuries before in the city of Tula (950-1150 AD)" 16. Its excavators have exposed some eighty-six metres of polychrome stone benches carved with processions of armed warriors converging on a ball of grass used in auto-sacrifice, copies in form and subject of the processional benches of Tula; its braziers, decorated with the face of Tlaloc, have been compared with an incense burner from Tula 1626. Healan and his colleagues note that the friezes of Tula's Edificio 4 closely resemble the House of Eagles benches 13.

The building's function made the borrowing political. It was where the dead king lay in vigil and where his successor performed rites before coronation 16. "In stage 2 of the House of Eagles," López Luján writes, "allusions to Toltec civilisation abound to convey to the faithful the idea of a glorious past" 16. A Mexica ruler went to his throne through rooms dressed as Tollan. López Luján's two-volume monograph on the building, La Casa de las Águilas, documents the programme stage by stage 26.

"The Tolteca were wise"

The Toltec name changed meaning in the Mexica language. In the chapter of the Florentine Codex devoted to the peoples of the land, the Nahua authors describe the Toltecs in terms that leave no doubt about the status of the inheritance. In David Jordan's translation from the Nahuatl: "The Tolteca were beautiful, all pure, all wise. Their works were all good, all perfect, all wonderful, all marvelous; their houses beautiful, tiled in mosaics, smoothed, stuccoed, very marvelous" 2120. The passage credits them with the arts, with writing and with the calendar, and names Tollan as "the place of worship of their priest, whose name was Quetzalcöatl" 21.

In sixteenth-century Nahuatl, toltecatl, "a Toltec", was the ordinary word for a skilled craftsman, and toltecayotl, "Toltec-ness", meant artistic excellence 20. The Mexica thus credited a single ruined city with the whole inheritance of Mesoamerican civilisation. The record shows otherwise. The 260-day calendar the Florentine Codex attributes to Toltec wisdom was already in use, in the orientation of ceremonial complexes, by 1100 BCE, two thousand years before Tula was built 5. The ballgame was played in formal courts more than a millennium before Tollan 7. The Feathered Serpent was carved at Teotihuacan eight centuries before Tula's Pyramid B 4. Tula was a late heir to traditions it did not invent, and the Mexica made it the origin of everything.

The calendar and the ball court

Two of the institutions the Mexica credited to the Toltecs ran through every part of their public life. The tonalpohualli combined twenty named days with the numbers one to thirteen to produce a cycle of 260 days, each with its own fortune, and priests consulted it to name children, choose days for war and trade, and schedule rites 2. Meshed with a 365-day solar year, it produced a cycle of fifty-two years, at the end of which every fire in the basin was extinguished and a new one drilled on the chest of a sacrificial victim on the Hill of the Star near Culhuacan. The Codex Telleriano-Remensis, painted in the mid-sixteenth century for Spanish readers, sets the days of the count beside the Feathered Serpent himself, devouring a man 25. The cycle was older than any Nahua city: it is the same count the San Bartolo painters wrote as "7 Deer" more than fifteen hundred years earlier, and the same count that Maya daykeepers in highland Guatemala still keep 6.

The ballgame was equally old and equally political. Mexica cities built I-shaped courts in their sacred precincts; at Tenochtitlan the court stood in the precinct beside the temple of Ehecatl-Quetzalcoatl and the great skull rack 30. The exhibition catalogue edited by Michael Whittington, The Sport of Life and Death, traces the game across three thousand years, from the earliest Gulf Coast and Pacific courts through Chichén Itzá's Great Ballcourt to the Mexica, and its association with sacrifice, fertility and the movement of the sun 7. When the Mexica credited such institutions to Tollan they were not wrong that Tula had them. They were wrong, or rather they chose to be silent, about the fact that Tula had inherited them too.

What was displaced

The Toltec inheritance did not only add. It pushed other things aside:

  • The older pictorial histories of the basin, in so far as they were burned or withdrawn under Itzcoatl, and with them whatever version of Mexica origins they had recorded 2223.
  • The claims of older houses. Culhuacan, whose Toltec descent the Mexica borrowed through Acamapichtli's mother, was absorbed into the empire; the lineage that had been its distinction became the Mexica's warrant 116.
  • Quetzalcoatl's primacy, demoted from the god of kingship in the Epiclassic network to a priestly title and a wind god's shrine beneath Huitzilopochtli's 2325.
  • The multi-centred network itself. A religion that had once linked Chichén, Xochicalco, Cholula and Tula on roughly equal terms was retold as the heritage of a single city, which the Mexica alone could claim to have inherited 819.
  • The memory of the Maya part of the story. In the Mexica account, Tollan's wisdom came from Tollan; Chichén Itzá, which may have been building in the Feathered Serpent style before Tula, does not figure as a source 811.

What the cost was

The Toltec inheritance was not a transmission between two living peoples, and it had no victims at the moment of borrowing in the sense that a conquest has. Its bill was paid in three other currencies: in records destroyed to make the claim exclusive, in lives taken under the imperial ideology the claim underwrote, and, after 1521, in the use of the Quetzalcoatl story against the people who had made it.

The cost in records

The first cost is the burning itself. No copy of the pre-Itzcoatl histories is known to survive, and we cannot know what they contained beyond what the Florentine Codex says about why they were destroyed: that the lords did not want the common people to know them, and that they contained what the lords now called lies 202223. The loss is permanent. The Mexica histories that scholars read today, the annals Townsend works from and the dynastic histories Gillespie analyses, all descend from the version that replaced them 13. Gillespie's verdict on what happened to that version after the conquest makes the loss compound: the dynastic history "was recast by its sixteenth-century recorders not merely to glorify ancestors but to make sense out of the trauma of conquest and colonialism" 3. What the modern reader has is a revision of a revision.

The cost in lives

The second cost is human sacrifice at the scale the empire practised it. Sacrifice was far older than the Mexica, as the burials at Teotihuacan's Feathered Serpent Pyramid show 4, and the Toltec claim did not create it. But the empire that justified itself through Toltec descent performed it as state spectacle, at its own temples, with captives taken in its wars. The figures for the largest single event, the rededication of the enlarged Templo Mayor under Ahuitzotl in 1487, are where the honest accounting has to start. Ximena Chávez Balderas, in a 2019 bioarchaeological study of the Templo Mayor sacrificial deposits, compiled the chronicle figures 27:

Source Date written Victims at the 1487 rededication
Codex Telleriano-Remensis, f. 39r c. 1550s–1560s 20,000
Juan de Torquemada 1615 60,000
Annals of Cuauhtitlan, year 8 Reed 1570 80,400 (16,000 Zapotecs, 24,000 Tlapanecs, 16,000 Huexotzinca, 24,400 others)
Diego Durán 1581 80,400 in four days (Durán himself doubts the figure)

The high figures were accepted by Christian Duverger and Marvin Harris; Yólotl González Torres objected that 80,400 deaths in four days would require "the slaughter of 47 individuals per hour, for 96 consecutive hours nonstop, in 20 places simultaneously" 27. Chávez Balderas concludes: "As for the number of victims associated to the consecration of the building, I consider these estimates quite doubtful" 27. She also notes where the inflation came from. The figures descend partly from the Mexica's own official history, which magnified the empire's power, and partly from Spanish chroniclers, "whose narratives were used to legitimize the conquest of the natives" 27. The Toltec-descended dynasty's own propaganda and its conquerors' propaganda converged on the same exaggeration.

The archaeology gives a floor rather than a ceiling. In 2015 archaeologists of INAH's urban archaeology programme found the Huei Tzompantli, the great skull rack of Tenochtitlan, beneath a house on Calle República de Guatemala 28:

  • 603 skulls had been identified in the structure by December 2020, including men, women and at least three children, according to the excavation team of Raúl Barrera Rodríguez and Lorena Vázquez Vallín 29.
  • Some 11,000 fragments are linked to the rack, which was built in five construction stages, at least one of them in the reign of Ahuitzotl (1486–1502) 2829.
  • Of 214 skulls cleaned and studied, 46.3 per cent were male and 37.4 per cent female; the remainder could not be sexed because they were incomplete or belonged to infants 28.
  • The rack measured about 34 by 12 metres; at five skulls to a pole, Chávez Balderas estimates a capacity of about 15,750, against the 136,000 that the conquistador Andrés de Tapia claimed to have counted 27.

The skull rack stood beside a ball court and the temple of Ehecatl-Quetzalcoatl, as Barrera's own report on the excavation makes clear: the Feathered Serpent's shrine and the empire's display of heads were neighbours 30.

The question of how these victims were obtained is contested. The traditional account holds that the empire fought "flowery wars" with Tlaxcala and other unconquered neighbours largely to take captives. Robert Martin's 2023 reassessment in Latin American Antiquity argues that captive-taking was not a major military objective, that sacrifice required relatively small numbers of victims obtainable in ordinary warfare, and that Mexica strategy prioritised tribute 31. Either way, the dead at the skull rack were real people, women and children among them, killed under the authority of a dynasty that claimed the right to rule through the Feathered Serpent.

The myth turned against its heirs

The third cost came after the empire fell. The best-known Quetzalcoatl story in the world is that the Mexica ruler Motecuhzoma took Hernán Cortés for the returning god in 1519 and so failed to resist him. Camilla Townsend's 2003 article in the American Historical Review dismantled it: "there is little evidence that indigenous people ever seriously believed the newcomers were gods, and there is no meaningful evidence that any story about Quetzalcoatl's returning from the east ever existed before the conquest" 32. The fully developed version appears in Francisco López de Gómara's history of the conquest around 1552, and in testimony gathered from Nahua informants a generation after the fall 32. The departure of Topiltzin Quetzalcoatl from Tollan, a legend that had served the Mexica dynasty as the proof of its descent, was retold as a prophecy of its own defeat, so that the conquered appeared to have surrendered to a destiny written in their own religion. Townsend's conclusion about the Mexica of 1519 is the corrective: "The Mexicans themselves immediately became aware of the technology gap and responded to it with intelligence and savvy rather than wide-eyed talk of gods" 32.

The first place in central Mexico to feel the conquest at full force was Quetzalcoatl's own city. Cholula, the network's principal pilgrimage shrine, was entered by Cortés in October 1519 with an army that included thousands of Tlaxcalan allies, the very enemies of the Mexica flower wars 34. On 18 October, after seizing about a hundred priests in the great ceremonial centre dedicated to Quetzalcoatl, the Spaniards and their allies killed the assembled Cholultecs, and the burning of the temples with their priests inside completed the taking of the city 34. Cortés reported to Charles V that "in two hours more than three thousand" had perished 33. When his conduct was examined in the residencia proceedings opened in 1529, his accusers, led by Bernardino Vázquez de Tapia, put the dead at up to twenty thousand. No one was ever convicted 34.

Books in the fire again

The last entry on the bill closes the circle the Mexica opened. In July 1562, at Maní in Yucatán, the Franciscan Diego de Landa presided over an auto-da-fé in which the surviving hieroglyphic books of the Maya, the civilisation at the far end of the Feathered Serpent network, were burned. Landa's own account, in Alfred Tozzer's translation, is the most quoted sentence in the history of Mesoamerican writing: "We found a large number of books in these characters and, as they contained nothing in which there were not to be seen superstition and lies of the devil, we burned them all, which they regretted to an amazing degree, and which caused them much affliction" 35. The justification is nearly word for word the one the Mexica lords gave a century and a quarter earlier: the books contained lies, and the people were better without them 2223. Only a handful of Maya books survive anywhere today.

The bill

Set out plainly, the cost of the Toltec inheritance was:

  • The pre-imperial histories of the Mexica and their neighbours, burned or withdrawn under Itzcoatl around the 1430s so that a single official past, joined to Tollan, could replace them 2223.
  • Thousands of sacrificial victims over the empire's ninety years, killed under a dynasty that claimed its right to rule through the Feathered Serpent: 603 skulls counted at the Huei Tzompantli by 2020, women and children among them, against chronicle figures of up to 80,400 for a single event that modern scholarship rejects 272829.
  • A legend turned into an alibi, the story of Quetzalcoatl's departure retold after 1521 to make the conquered complicit in their conquest 32.
  • Cholula, Quetzalcoatl's city, where at least 3,000 and perhaps many more people were killed on 18 October 1519, and nobody was convicted 3334.
  • The Maya books of Maní, burned in 1562 on grounds the Mexica lords had already used 35.

The rating holds at 3. The burning of the histories was a deliberate and permanent act of erasure, carried out to make the Toltec claim exclusive, and the sacrifices performed by the dynasty that made the claim were real and numerous, with women and children among the dead. Those two facts would justify a higher rating if the claim had caused them. It did not, quite. Sacrifice predated the claim by more than a thousand years and would have continued without it; the Feathered Serpent was already a god of war and offering at Teotihuacan 4. The violence of 1519 and after was the conquerors' own, and the Quetzalcoatl legend was made into an alibi by others, after the fact 32. And the transmission itself, the borrowing of a dead city's forms and a living town's bloodline, was carried out without war against the source. What the record can say with confidence is that the inheritance was bought with the destruction of a people's own memory, and that it became the language in which an empire of tribute and sacrifice justified itself.

The Mexica wanted to be the heirs of the people who invented civilisation. To become heirs they had to destroy the record of what they had been, and after their fall the inheritance they had built was used to explain why they had lost.

What followed

Where this lives today

The 260-day count still kept by Maya daykeepers in highland Guatemala Quetzalcoatl as a symbol of Mexican national identity Nahuatl toltecayotl, "Toltec-ness", as a word for artistic excellence The Templo Mayor and House of Eagles excavations in Mexico City The Cortés-as-Quetzalcoatl legend in popular histories of the conquest

References

  1. Townsend, Camilla. Fifth Sun: A New History of the Aztecs. New York: Oxford University Press, 2019. en
  2. Smith, Michael E. The Aztecs. 3rd ed. The Peoples of America. Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell, 2012. en
  3. Gillespie, Susan D. The Aztec Kings: The Construction of Rulership in Mexica History. Tucson: University of Arizona Press, 1989. en
  4. Sugiyama, Saburo. Human Sacrifice, Militarism, and Rulership: Materialization of State Ideology at the Feathered Serpent Pyramid, Teotihuacan. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2005. en
  5. Šprajc, Ivan, Takeshi Inomata, and Anthony F. Aveni. "Origins of Mesoamerican Astronomy and Calendar: Evidence from the Olmec and Maya Regions." Science Advances 9, no. 1 (2023): eabq7675. en
  6. Stuart, David, Heather Hurst, Boris Beltrán, and William Saturno. "An Early Maya Calendar Record from San Bartolo, Guatemala." Science Advances 8, no. 15 (2022): eabl9290. en
  7. Whittington, E. Michael, ed. The Sport of Life and Death: The Mesoamerican Ballgame. New York: Thames & Hudson; Charlotte: Mint Museum of Art, 2001. en
  8. Ringle, William M., Tomás Gallareta Negrón, and George J. Bey III. "The Return of Quetzalcoatl: Evidence for the Spread of a World Religion during the Epiclassic Period." Ancient Mesoamerica 9, no. 2 (1998): 183–232. en
  9. Kowalski, Jeff Karl, and Cynthia Kristan-Graham, eds. Twin Tollans: Chichén Itzá, Tula, and the Epiclassic to Early Postclassic Mesoamerican World. Rev. ed. Washington, DC: Dumbarton Oaks Research Library and Collection, 2011. en
  10. Tozzer, Alfred M. Chichen Itza and Its Cenote of Sacrifice: A Comparative Study of Contemporaneous Maya and Toltec. 2 vols. Memoirs of the Peabody Museum of Archaeology and Ethnology 11–12. Cambridge, MA: Peabody Museum, Harvard University, 1957. en
  11. Gillespie, Susan D. "Toltecs, Tula, and Chichén Itzá: The Development of an Archaeological Myth." In Twin Tollans, edited by Jeff Karl Kowalski and Cynthia Kristan-Graham, 85–128. Washington, DC: Dumbarton Oaks, 2007. en
  12. Mastache, Alba Guadalupe, Robert H. Cobean, and Dan M. Healan. Ancient Tollan: Tula and the Toltec Heartland. Boulder: University Press of Colorado, 2002. en
  13. Healan, Dan M., Robert H. Cobean, and Robert T. Bowsher. "Revised Chronology and Settlement History of Tula and the Tula Region." Ancient Mesoamerica 32, no. 1 (2021): 165–186. en
  14. Cobean, Robert H., and Alba Guadalupe Mastache Flores. "La Tollan histórica." Arqueología Mexicana 14, no. 85 (2007). es
  15. Bierhorst, John, trans. History and Mythology of the Aztecs: The Codex Chimalpopoca. Tucson: University of Arizona Press, 1992. (Annals of Cuauhtitlan; Legend of the Suns.) nah primary
  16. López Luján, Leonardo. "The House of Eagles." In Aztecs, edited by Doris Kurella, Martin Berger, and Inés de Castro, 227–235. Munich: Hirmer, for the Linden-Museum Stuttgart, 2019. en
  17. López Luján, Leonardo, and Alfredo López Austin. "The Mexica in Tula and Tula in Mexico-Tenochtitlan." In The Art of Urbanism: How Mesoamerican Kingdoms Represented Themselves in Architecture and Imagery, edited by William L. Fash and Leonardo López Luján, 384–422. Washington, DC: Dumbarton Oaks, 2009. en
  18. López Austin, Alfredo, and Leonardo López Luján. "Los mexicas en Tula y Tula en México-Tenochtitlan." Estudios de Cultura Náhuatl 38 (2007): 33–83. es
  19. López Austin, Alfredo, and Leonardo López Luján. Mito y realidad de Zuyuá: Serpiente Emplumada y las transformaciones mesoamericanas del Clásico al Posclásico. Mexico City: El Colegio de México / Fideicomiso Historia de las Américas / Fondo de Cultura Económica, 1999. es
  20. Sahagún, Bernardino de. Florentine Codex: General History of the Things of New Spain. Book 10, The People. Translated by Arthur J. O. Anderson and Charles E. Dibble. Santa Fe: School of American Research; Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press, 1961. nah primary
  21. Jordan, David K., trans. "The Toltecs" (Florentine Codex, Book 10, ch. 29), Aztec Folio. University of California, San Diego. en primary
  22. Sahagún, Bernardino de. Historia general de las cosas de Nueva España. Edited by Alfredo López Austin and Josefina García Quintana. Mexico City: Consejo Nacional para la Cultura y las Artes, 2002. Libro X, cap. XXIX. es primary
  23. Battcock, Clementina. "Acerca de las pinturas que se quemaron y la reescritura de la historia en tiempos de Itzcóatl. Una revisión desde la perspectiva simbólica." Estudios de Cultura Náhuatl 43 (2012): 95–113. es
  24. Graulich, Michel. Quetzalcóatl y el espejismo de Tollan. Antwerp: Instituut voor Amerikanistiek, 1988. es
  25. Sahagún, Bernardino de. Florentine Codex: General History of the Things of New Spain. Book 3, The Origin of the Gods. Translated by Arthur J. O. Anderson and Charles E. Dibble. Santa Fe: School of American Research; Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press. Appendix, on the priests; see also Gran Diccionario Náhuatl, s.v. "quetzalcoatl" (UNAM). nah primary
  26. López Luján, Leonardo. La Casa de las Águilas: un ejemplo de la arquitectura religiosa de Tenochtitlan. 2 vols. Mexico City: Fondo de Cultura Económica / INAH / Harvard University, 2006. es
  27. Chávez Balderas, Ximena María. "The Offering of Life: Human and Animal Sacrifice at the West Plaza of the Sacred Precinct of Tenochtitlan." PhD diss., Tulane University, 2019. en
  28. Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia. "A 10 años del hallazgo del Huei Tzompantli de Tenochtitlan, los cráneos humanos son objeto de análisis de vanguardia." Boletín 383. Mexico City: INAH, 11 August 2025. es primary
  29. "Descubren 119 cráneos del Huei Tzompantli en calle del Centro Histórico." El Financiero (Mexico City), 11 December 2020 (reporting INAH). es
  30. Barrera Rodríguez, Raúl. "The Huei Tzompantli, the Ball Game and the Temple of Ehecatl Quetzalcoatl." In Aztecs, edited by Doris Kurella, Martin Berger, and Inés de Castro, 237ff. Munich: Hirmer, for the Linden-Museum Stuttgart, 2019. en
  31. Martin, Robert William. "A Reevaluation of the Role of War Captives in the Aztec Empire." Latin American Antiquity 34, no. 2 (2023): 423–437. en
  32. Townsend, Camilla. "Burying the White Gods: New Perspectives on the Conquest of Mexico." American Historical Review 108, no. 3 (2003): 659–687. en
  33. Cortés, Hernán. Second letter to Charles V, 30 October 1520. In Cartas y relaciones de Hernan Cortés al emperador Carlos V, 68–69. English excerpt: "Cortés Meets Cholulans," American Historical Association. See also Letters from Mexico, translated and edited by Anthony Pagden. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1986. es primary
  34. Bautista y Lugo, Gibran. "Morir de mala muerte. De la cumbre del Popocatépetl al juicio por la matanza de Cholula." Noticonquista. Mexico City: Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, 2019. es
  35. Landa, Diego de. Landa's Relación de las cosas de Yucatán: A Translation. Edited and translated by Alfred M. Tozzer. Papers of the Peabody Museum of American Archaeology and Ethnology 18. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University, 1941. es primary
  36. Bey, George J., III, and William M. Ringle. "From the Bottom Up: The Timing and Nature of the Tula–Chichén Itzá Exchange." In Twin Tollans, edited by Jeff Karl Kowalski and Cynthia Kristan-Graham, 377–427. Washington, DC: Dumbarton Oaks, 2007. en

Further reading

Cite this article
OsakaWire Atlas. 2026. "The Toltec past the Mexica claimed (c. 1430) — and the books burned" [Hidden Threads record]. https://osakawire.com/en/atlas/feathered_serpent_toltec_to_mexica_1430/