Norse iron for the Thule Inuit (c. 1300) — and a colony that vanished
From the thirteenth century the Thule Inuit, newly arrived from Alaska, and the Norse farmers of south-west Greenland shared the same coast. Norse chain mail, ship rivets and iron blades turned up in Inuit houses two thousand kilometres north of the farms, and were cut down into harpoon tips. The Inuit took the metal and left the rest. The Norse took nothing of the Inuit way of living on the ice, and by about 1450 their colony was gone. Three centuries later, a Danish mission sent to find them colonised the Inuit instead.
In 1936 a Danish archaeologist digging Inuit houses on Ruin Island, off the far north-west coast of Greenland, found Norse objects more than 2,000 kilometres from the nearest Norse farm. Across Smith Sound, Thule winter houses on Ellesmere Island held chain mail, ship rivets and woollen cloth. For two centuries the Thule Inuit, newly arrived from Alaska, and the Norse farmers of south-west Greenland lived within reach of each other. The Inuit took iron and wood and cut them into their own tools. The Norse learned nothing of hunting on the winter sea ice. The Icelandic annals record eighteen Greenlanders killed in 1379. By about 1450 the colony was gone, and the Inuit remained.
Before: the people who came east with the whale
In the thirteenth century a new people arrived on the coasts of north-west Greenland. They had come from the far side of the continent. Their ancestors had lived on the shores of northern Alaska, where the culture archaeologists call Thule took shape around 1000 CE, and in a few generations they had crossed the whole Canadian Arctic. The National Museum of Denmark's summary of the evidence is plain: the culture "developed around 1000 AD in North Alaska it spread eastwards along the Arctic shores of North America to Labrador and Greenland, which was reached approximately 1200 AD" 4. The speed of that movement is now the best-established fact about it. When T. Max Friesen and Charles Arnold redated the early Thule sites of the western Canadian Arctic in 2008, using short-lived materials instead of the driftwood and sea-mammal bone that had inflated earlier dates, they found "that neither site was occupied before the thirteenth century A.D." 2. The older chronology, which had the Thule reaching the eastern High Arctic around 1050, collapsed; what replaced it was a migration of several thousand kilometres inside a century or two 218.
The people who made that journey are the direct ancestors of the Inuit of Canada and of the Kalaallit, the Greenlanders. Ancient DNA confirms the line. A genome study of ancient and modern Arctic peoples published in Science in 2014 found that the arrival of the Thule represented "a new population, representing the ancestors of present-day Inuit" 3. Nothing in this record's subject was carried by a vanished people. The receiving culture is still there, and still speaks the language its thirteenth-century travellers spoke.
A tool kit built for sea ice
The Thule moved fast because they carried an economy that worked on the ice and at its edge. Its parts were not new — most had been developed over centuries around the Bering Strait — but together they let a small band live almost anywhere a sea mammal could be killed 14:
- The umiak, a large open boat of split driftwood or bone lashed into a frame and covered with walrus or bearded-seal hide, able to carry a household, its dogs and its gear along an open coast in summer.
- The kayak, a one-person hunting boat with the same skin-on-frame construction, for approaching seals and walrus on open water.
- The toggling harpoon with a detachable head, a line and an inflated sealskin float, which turned inside the wound and held a large animal until it tired.
- Communal bowhead whaling from umiaks, which could supply a settlement with meat, oil and bone for a winter from a single animal.
- Dog traction, which made winter travel and hunting at seal breathing-holes on the sea ice possible over long distances.
- Semi-subterranean winter houses of stone, turf and whale bone, entered by a cold-trap tunnel, lit and heated by soapstone lamps burning seal or whale oil.
The National Museum's summary catches how the system was organised: "Sealing played a major role for local communities on an individual level, while whaling and caribou hunting took place as communal activities involving strategic co-operation" 4. Stable-isotope analysis of some sixty-five Thule individuals from Greenland confirms what the tool kit implies. As D. Erle Nelson, Niels Lynnerup and Jette Arneborg put it, "these people were almost entirely dependent on the marine biosphere for their protein" 26.

What the Thule did not have
The tool kit had one structural shortage, and it is the one that matters for this record. The Thule were a culture of wood and metal without a supply of either. Trees do not grow on the coasts they crossed; the umiak frame, the kayak frame, the sledge runner, the bow and the harpoon shaft all depended on driftwood, which arrives unpredictably and rarely in the lengths a boat-builder wants. Edged tools were of stone, bone, antler and ivory, and the cutting edges of knives and harpoon heads were the parts that wore out fastest.
Metal was known, but rare. In north-west Greenland a few hundred kilometres south of the Thule landfall lay the iron meteorites of Cape York, from which both the Dorset people and the Thule hammered small flakes into blades. The metallurgist Vagn Fabritius Buchwald, who examined the iron of Greenland's archaeological sites over decades, identified the northernmost and largest meteoritic iron tool known, a lancehead from Washington Land 6. That was the ceiling of the Arctic's own metal supply: cold-worked flakes from a single source, distributed along the coast by exchange. A blade of smelted iron, of the kind a European smith could forge in a day, was something no one on these coasts could make.
The Tuniit, and an older encounter
The Thule were not entering an empty land. The eastern Arctic had been inhabited for four thousand years by the peoples archaeologists call Palaeo-Eskimo, whose last phase is the Dorset culture, and whom Inuit oral tradition calls the Tuniit. The 2014 genome study found that "a single Paleo-Eskimo metapopulation likely survived in near-isolation for more than 4000 years, only to vanish around 700 years ago" — that is, within a century or two of the Thule arrival 3. The same study detected old gene flow between the two lineages, but that exchange is generally placed long before, in the two peoples' common ancestral population in Siberia; within the Arctic itself, the two peoples left no genetic trace in each other 3.
This matters to the Norse story in two ways. First, the "skrælings" of the earliest Norse text may not be Thule at all. The Historia Norwegie, a Latin history of Norway written in the late twelfth century, reports that hunters north of the Greenlanders had met small people, homunciones, who had no iron, used walrus tusk for missiles and sharpened stones for knives 7. Hans Christian Gulløv of the National Museum of Denmark, the principal modern scholar of the encounter, argues that the date gives "good reason to assume that the Skrælíngja mentioned may have been Paleo-Eskimo Dorset people" 5. Second, the late Dorset of north-west Greenland had already handled Norse metal: at one Late Dorset site in the region, Gulløv records, alongside "considerable amounts of meteoric iron derived from the source near Cape York," excavators found "a fragment of a brass pot of Norse origin" 5. The three peoples — Tuniit, Norse and Inuit — were briefly in the same northern waters in the thirteenth century, a meeting Gulløv and Martin Appelt have reconstructed as a three-way contest over the same hunting grounds 8. A further claim, that the Norse had a lasting presence among the Dorset on southern Baffin Island, rests on Patricia Sutherland's finds of spun yarn and cordage at Dorset sites, the "strands" of her title, later joined by claims of early metalworking at the Tanfield Valley site 20. It remains contested: Michèle Hayeur Smith, Kevin Smith and Gørill Nilsen's radiocarbon dating of the yarn found that most of it predates any Norse arrival, which points to Dorset spinning rather than Norse contact 44. This record keeps that Dorset question separate from the Thule encounter, which rests on firmer ground.
The transmission: a farm colony at the end of the line
The other party to the meeting was a farming people who had come from the opposite direction. Around 985, according to the saga tradition, Eiríkr rauði (Erik the Red) led Icelandic settlers to the fjords of south-west Greenland 11. They established two clusters of farms: the Eastern Settlement around modern Qaqortoq and Narsaq, and the smaller Western Settlement in the fjords east of modern Nuuk. They kept cattle, sheep and goats, built turf longhouses and stone churches, and in 1124 obtained their own bishop from the Norwegian king, with a cathedral seat at Garðar 11. In 1261 Greenland was formally attached to the Norwegian realm 11.
They were few. Niels Lynnerup's biological-anthropological study of the Norse skeletons concludes that "a founder population of about 500 people could well have increased to about 2,000 over 200 years," and that the colony's total population over its whole life was around 26,000 people, an average of 1,400 at any one time 9. Arnved Nedkvitne, of the University of Oslo, puts the peak a little higher, at 2,000 to 3,000 37. Jette Arneborg's standard Danish survey, in Gulløv's Grønlands forhistorie, brackets the colony in its title: Nordboerne i Grønland, 985–1450 10.
A European economy short of what Europe ran on
The colony was a European farming economy at the end of a long supply line, and it was short of exactly the materials the Thule were short of. Greenland has scrub birch and willow but no timber; and it has little iron of its own. The Norse needed wood for houses, boats and barrels, and iron for tools and weapons, and had to import both, or find them elsewhere — the motive that drove their ships to Labrador and Newfoundland around 1000 (see the related record on Vinland).
What paid for those imports was the Arctic. Isotope studies of the Norse dead have dismantled the old image of a cattle-farming people who would not eat from the sea. In the first study, Arneborg and her colleagues found that "between 20 and 30% of the diet of the early 11th century settlers was marine in origin," and that "in the late settlement period in the first half of the 15th century AD, however, up to about 80% of the food of some Norse Greenlanders was of marine origin" 12. An analysis of eighty individuals from seven churchyards concluded that "the basic dietary economy was based about as much on hunting as it was on their domestic animals" 13. The Norse ate seal, mostly migratory harp seals taken in communal drives in spring 24. They were hunters as well as farmers — but hunters of a particular, European-organised kind.
North to the walrus
The export was walrus ivory. Ancient DNA studies of medieval European walrus artefacts by Bastiaan Star, James Barrett and their colleagues show "a significant shift in trade from an early, predominantly eastern source towards a near exclusive representation of Greenland ivory," and conclude that the Greenland supply was "progressively integrated into a medieval pan-European trade network, contributing to both the resilience and vulnerability of Norse Greenland society" 14. A follow-up study of walrus rostra — skulls with tusks attached, the form in which ivory was shipped — found that "almost all medieval European finds of walrus rostra likely derived from Greenland," and that over time "more and smaller animals were targeted at increasingly untenable distances, which reflects a classic pattern of resource depletion" 15.
Those distances took the Norse north, out of the zone they farmed and into the zone the Thule were entering. Their summer hunting grounds lay around Disko Bay and beyond, hundreds of kilometres north of the Western Settlement. In 2024 a genomic study of walrus remains from Norse sites traced the animals to specific hunting grounds and found "that Greenland Norse obtained ivory from High Arctic waters, especially the North Water Polynya, and possibly from the interior Canadian Arctic" — the very waters of Smith Sound where the earliest Thule houses in Greenland stand 16. The authors say directly that this supports "intriguing archaeological evidence for substantive interactions with Thule Inuit, plus possible encounters with Tuniit" 16.

The Norse left one signed record of how far north they went. On the island of Kingittorsuaq, near Upernavik at about 72°55′ N, a small stone found in the 1820s carries a runic inscription naming three men — Erlingr Sighvatsson, Bjarni Þórðarson and Eindriði Oddsson — who "constructed these cairns the Saturday before Rogation Day" 17. Lisbeth Imer's corpus of the Greenland inscriptions treats it as the northernmost runic text known; its date is usually given within c. 1250–1333 and remains debated 17. The men were roughly a thousand kilometres north of the nearest Norse farm, in the spring, in the zone where the Thule were travelling.
Where the objects went: Ellesmere and Ruin Island
The objects tell the story the texts do not. In 1936 the Danish archaeologist Erik Holtved excavated six house ruins on Ruin Island, off Inglefield Land in the far north-west of Greenland. As Gulløv recounts, it "took the eskimologist Erik Holtved by surprise when, in 1936, he excavated six ruins on Ruin Island off the coast of Inglefield Land, and found Norse objects more than 2000 kilometres north of the Western Settlement of Greenland" 5. The houses were early Thule, and gave their name to the Ruin Island phase, the first Thule horizon in Greenland.
Across Smith Sound, on the east coast of Ellesmere Island, Peter Schledermann and Karen McCullough excavated Thule winter houses on Skraeling Island and the Bache Peninsula from 1978 into the 1990s. They found one of the largest concentrations of Norse material known from North America, in houses dated to the thirteenth century: pieces of chain mail, iron ship rivets, woven woollen cloth, knife and spear blades, an iron point, pieces of copper, a carpenter's plane, and, at a nearby site, a barrel bottom and part of a wooden box 1819. The excavators proposed that one or more Norse ships had been caught in the ice of Smith Sound and salvaged by the people living there; as Gulløv summarises, "the recovery of iron rivets, interpreted as ship rivets, led the Canadian archaeologists to advance the theory that one or more ships had been icebound in High Arctic waters and had supplied local natives with metal and other exotic objects" 5.
Wreck or trade, the material spread. Patricia Sutherland's survey for the Canadian Museum of Civilization concluded that "fragments of smelted iron, copper, and bronze recovered from Thule sites throughout the eastern Arctic, as well as a specimen from the Central Arctic coast which may be of Norse origin, indicate an extensive aboriginal trade network and provide evidence for the high value of Norse materials in the Inuit economy" 20. She also recorded "a portion of a bronze trade balance from a Thule site on the western coast of Ellesmere Island" — part of the folding scales a Norse merchant used to weigh silver 20.
A Norseman carved in wood
The most direct evidence that the Thule looked closely at the Norse is a figure five centimetres high. In 1977 excavators on the south coast of Baffin Island recovered from a Thule house a wooden carving of a person in a long garment. Deborah and George Sabo, who published it in 1978, wrote that it "was probably made by a prehistoric Thule culture Eskimo in the 13th century A.D., and is thought to be a depiction of a Viking man from Greenland. The clothing style shown on the figurine compares well with front-slit or gored tunics and yoked hoods of the 11th through 13th centuries. The carving also wears a cross on the chest" 21. The Sabos were careful to add that "there is insufficient evidence to discuss the significance of such contact" 21. The museum now dates the figure to around 1350; Sutherland puts its site in the thirteenth or fourteenth century 20. Gulløv records similar figurines from north-west Greenland "representing the Norse in their characteristic garments" 5.
Sandhavn and the outer fjords
By the fourteenth century the Thule had moved south along the west coast into the outer fjords of the Norse settlement areas. A 2018 review by Rowan Jackson, Jette Arneborg and their colleagues states that "by the fourteenth century, Thule culture had advanced to the outer-fjords of the Norse settlement areas, most likely for summer trading" 23. The best evidence for that trading place is Sandhavn, a sheltered harbour on the south coast 3.5 kilometres from the Norse farm and churchyard of Herjolfsnes. Kirsty Golding and her colleagues found that "ruins representing both medieval Norse and Inuit (Thule culture) settlements can be found together on the coast at Sandhavn," with a Thule structure dated to the thirteenth or fourteenth century, and suggested that the harbour's role as "a harbor and possible trading area may have attracted Inuit settlers keen to participate in European trade networks" 22.
The exchange was not one-way. Buchwald identified an arrowhead from a Western Settlement farm that was made of Cape York meteoritic iron and "must have been traded to the Norsemen before 1350 AD" 6. Gulløv records the side prong of a Thule bird dart found on an Eastern Settlement farm 5. Iron went north to the Thule, a little Arctic iron came south to the Norse, and the walrus tusks in a Bergen merchant's warehouse may, in their last decades, have passed through Inuit hands before Norse ones; in presenting the 2020 study, its Cambridge authors suggested that the rising share of small female animals in later exports could reflect growing Norse reliance on Inuit supply 1516.
What changed, and what was replaced
What the Inuit took from the Norse can be listed. What they did not take can also be listed, and the second list is the more surprising.
Metal into an Arctic economy
The material is consistent across sites from Baffin Island to Inglefield Land 518192021:
| Object | Where found | Context and date | What it became |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chain-mail sections | Skraeling Island, Ellesmere | Thule winter houses, 13th century | Raw metal; links cut and reworked |
| Iron ship rivets | Skraeling Island | Same houses | Raw iron for blades and points |
| Knife and spear blades, iron point | Skraeling Island | Same houses | Re-hafted cutting edges |
| Woollen cloth | Skraeling Island | Same houses | Exotic material, kept |
| Carpenter's plane, barrel bottom, box | Ellesmere east coast | Thule sites | Worked wood, reused |
| Bronze balance-arm fragment | Ellesmere west coast | Thule site | Copper alloy |
| Chess pieces | Ruin Island, Inglefield Land | Ruin Island phase, 13th century | Curiosities; no game |
| Brass pot fragment | Late Dorset site, north-west Greenland | 13th century | Copper alloy |
| Smelted iron, copper, bronze | Thule sites across the eastern Arctic | 13th–15th centuries | Blades, points, ornaments |
| Wooden figure in European dress | South Baffin Island | Thule house, 13th–14th century | A carving of a Norse person |
The pattern is clear. The Thule took metal and wood, which their economy needed and could not produce, and they worked them into their own tools. A Norse iron rivet became the tip of a harpoon head; a piece of chain mail became a set of small blades. The value Sutherland identified lay in the material, not in the European form 20. Robert McGhee's 1984 review of all the evidence for contact concluded that "occasional contacts involving both trade and plundering probably occurred over a period of several centuries," and that "there is no evidence to indicate that these contacts had any major influence on aboriginal North American populations" 25.
What the Inuit did not take
The objects that crossed over without their uses are as telling as the iron. Gulløv points to the chessmen from the Ruin Island houses: "chess has never existed among prehistoric Arctic cultures" 5. Jackson and her co-authors draw the general conclusion, following Gulløv: such objects "may have conveyed a (new) symbolic value but use-value is improbable without a compatible knowledge of the other culture" 23. The record does not support the claims sometimes made that the Inuit learned smithing, adopted Norse boat-building or took over Norse clothing. No study located for this record establishes a Norse loanword in Kalaallisut beyond the one possible case discussed below. The Thule did not need a European way of life. They needed its materials, and they took them on their own terms.
What changed, then, was not a culture but a supply. Smelted iron, which in a European village was the ordinary material of nails and knives, became for two centuries a scarce, high-value addition to an Arctic economy that already knew how to use metal from the Cape York meteorites 6. It sharpened an existing tool kit. It did not replace it. When European iron arrived in quantity, it arrived much later, with the Dutch and English whalers of the late sixteenth century and after; Buchwald's analyses show that many of the iron tools in Inuit sites are of this later "Walloon" iron, forged by ships' smiths "according to the desires of the Inuit" 6. The medieval Norse iron was a prelude, not a transformation.
What the Norse did not take
On the Norse side the omission is larger. The Thule arrived with the most successful Arctic hunting technology in the world, and the Norse, who were themselves dependent on seals for much of their food by the fourteenth century, did not adopt it. Andrew Dugmore, Thomas McGovern, Orri Vésteinsson, Jette Arneborg and their colleagues note that "the bearded and ringed seals that use winter breathing holes and do not form large seasonal concentrations are rare in Norse archaeofauna, but they are common in Inuit sites alongside artifacts associated with elaborate sea ice hunting technology" 24. The Norse hunted harp seals in spring drives, the way their ancestors had hunted in the North Atlantic. They never learned to take the seals that stayed through the winter.
The same authors are careful about why. "Inuit sea ice hunting gear is complex and requires a special set of hunting skills very different to those of the communal harp seal drives. Its successful adoption would probably have required close cooperative interaction between Norse and Inuit hunters" 24. That interaction did not happen on any scale that left a trace. Here the evidence turns on a single archaeological fact, which Gulløv states without qualification: "The archaeology shows that Eskimo winter sites were established in Norse settlement areas only after the Norse settlements were abandoned" 5. The Thule summered at the edges of Norse territory, and perhaps traded at harbours like Sandhavn. They did not winter among the Norse, which is when sea-ice hunting is learned.
The name, and the memory
Two things the Inuit may have taken were not objects. Gulløv reports a long-standing view that kalaaleq, the Greenlanders' name for themselves (plural Kalaallit), "cannot be of Greenlandic origin" and is supposed to derive from a Norse word, and he records an eighteenth-century tradition that the name "was introduced by the old Christian, who earlier lived in their country" 5. The etymology is a hypothesis, not a finding. If it is right, the most enduring trace of the Norse in Greenland is the name the country's people still use for themselves.
The second was memory. When the Danish geologist and administrator Hinrich Rink collected Greenlandic tales in the 1850s and 1860s, he found a cycle about the Kavdlunait — the old foreigners — "known only to the west Greenlanders, especially the southernmost of them, and representing the only trace of intelligence left concerning the ancient Scandinavian settlers which the author has been able to discover by inquiries made in the country" 40. Some of the tales remember peace: near the Nuuk fjords, "the foreigners began to learn their language. At Kapisilik a Kavdlunak and a Kalalek, it is said, became such fast friends that they would not be separated" 40. Others remember killing, and are taken up in the next section. Rink published them first in Danish in 1866 and in English in 1875 4140, and the Greenlandic artist Aron of Kangeq illustrated them between 1857 and 1861 in a series of woodcut prints now held by the National Gallery of Denmark (the print at the head of this record). Robert Rix's 2023 study of the legend's history is a necessary caution: these tales were solicited and written down by missionaries and colonial officials, and printed by Europeans looking for the lost Norse 42. They are Inuit memory, but memory recorded through a Danish question.
What the cost was
The cost of this transmission is unusual in the atlas. The receiving culture was not conquered, enslaved or decimated by it. The European party disappeared. The bill is small in the written record, larger in the silence that follows it, and largest in what was done three centuries later in the Norse colonists' name.
1379: eighteen men and two boys
The only written record of violence between the Norse and the Inuit in Greenland is a single annal entry. Under the year 1379 the Icelandic annal known as Gottskálksannáll, edited by Gustav Storm in 1888, records that the skrælingar attacked the Greenlanders, killed eighteen men and took two boys, whom they made thralls 28. In the English of Dugmore and his colleagues, "the Skrælings attacked the Greenlanders, killed 18 men and captured two boys" 24. The annal was compiled in its surviving form in the sixteenth century, and it does not say where in Greenland the attack happened or why.
That entry carries a great deal of weight in the scholarship, because there is almost nothing else. Nedkvitne reads it, with the other late Norse references to skrælings, as evidence of organised Inuit violence that brought the colony down 37. Gulløv reads the contact as mainly economic and the violence as episodic 5. Dugmore and his colleagues conclude only that "Norse references after the early 13th century suggest growing conflict with people that they called Skrælings" 24. The eighteen men are the colony's only recorded dead in the encounter. The two boys are its only recorded captives. Their names are not known.
The Western Settlement: "no man, Christian or heathen"
In the middle of the fourteenth century the cleric Ívar Bárðarson, steward of the bishop's estates at Garðar while the see stood vacant from 1341 to 1364, took part in an expedition north to the Western Settlement 27. His account survives only in a sixteenth-century Danish translation of a lost Norse original. It reports that the expedition found "ingen Mand, endten christenn eller heden, uden noget villdt Fæ og Faaer" — no man, either Christian or heathen, only some wild cattle and sheep 27. The same account, as quoted by Dugmore and his colleagues, says that "now the Skrælings have desolated the whole of the Western Settlement" 24.
Whether that sentence is an eyewitness judgement or a later gloss is unknowable. The archaeology complicates the dating. Radiocarbon studies of the Norse dead and their animals support "a later date—around 1400—for the depopulation of the Western Settlement than was previously believed" 12, which would make Ívar's expedition a visit to a settlement in trouble rather than one already gone. The farms were left; the people went, or died, and the record does not say which.

Hvalsey, 1408, and the last letter
The Eastern Settlement lasted longer. In 1378 its last resident bishop, Álfr, died, and no successor came 2811. In September 1408 two Icelanders, Þorsteinn Ólafsson and Sigríður Björnsdóttir, were married in the stone church at Hvalsey, in what Georg Nyegaard describes as "the last written evidence for life in Norse Greenland" 30. On 19 April 1409 the priests Eindriði Andrésson and Páll Hallvarðsson issued a letter at Garðar certifying that the marriage in Hvalsey church the year before had been made according to the holy rules of the Church 29. After that letter the written record of Norse Greenland ends.
The Herjolfsnes churchyard, excavated by Poul Nørlund in 1921, shows that the last people buried there were dressed in hoods and gowns cut to late-medieval European patterns 31: the colony was still in some contact with the European world, or at least with its fashions, in the fifteenth century. The Eastern Settlement was abandoned during that century. Arneborg's survey dates its end to about 1450 10; Nedkvitne to about 1415 37. No grave of the last Norse Greenlander has been identified, and no document records how the last of them died or where they went.
Why the colony ended: the debate
There is no consensus, and this record will not invent one. Arneborg's 2023 chapter for the Cambridge History of the Polar Regions sets out the field in one sentence: "For almost 500 years the Norse population in Greenland thrived, and then it vanished for reasons not yet fully understood" 38. The principal positions are these:
- Inflexible elites and maladaptation. Thomas McGovern's 1980 study argued that an elite which controlled information and decisions held the colony to a conservative European pattern of cattle, churches and ivory that, under Inuit competition and a worsening climate, became fatal 32. Jared Diamond's Collapse (2005) made the argument moral, as a society that chose to fail rather than learn from the Inuit 33. Joel Berglund, formerly of the Greenland National Museum, answered with the question in his title: "Did the Medieval Norse Society in Greenland Really Fail?" 34.
- Trade and the ivory trap. Dugmore, Christian Keller and McGovern, revising McGovern's earlier view, argued in 2007 that "changing economies and patterns of trade, rather than climatic deterioration, could have critically marginalized the Norse Greenland settlements and effectively sealed their fate" 35. The walrus DNA studies show an ivory economy chasing ever smaller animals ever farther north 15.
- Climate. Sustained cooling from the mid-thirteenth century is documented 23; a 2022 study of lake sediments beside a Norse farm in the Eastern Settlement found that drought, more than cold, would have cut the hay harvest on which the cattle depended 36. Christian Koch Madsen and Ann Eileen Lennert found no evidence that the cooling had an immediate impact on Norse settlement in Nunatarsuaq 46.
- Inuit violence. Nedkvitne's 2019 book argues for organised Inuit attacks as a principal cause 37; Arneborg cites the argument as one possibility among several 38.
- Emigration, not extinction. Kirsten Seaver argued in The Frozen Echo (1996) that the Greenlanders remained in contact with English and other North Atlantic sailors into the fifteenth century, and that the end may have come through departure rather than death 39.
The 2012 study by Dugmore and his co-authors has the most measured framing: a society that achieved "successful arctic adaptation," and was undone by compounding vulnerabilities rather than by a single error 24. What every position shares is that the Inuit were present, expanding, and better adapted to the climate that was arriving, and that the Norse did not draw on what they knew.
Kaisape and Ungortok: what the Inuit remembered
The Inuit tales recorded by Rink do not describe a peaceful meeting. The longest of them, "Ungortok, the Chief of Kakortok," is set at Qaqortoq, near the ruins of Hvalsey. A kayaker from Akpaitsivik kills a Norseman gathering mussels; the Norse chief Ungortok at first lets the killing pass — in Rink's Danish he says, "jeg har selv opfordret dig dertil, derfor gjorde du det" ("I myself urged you to do it, that is why you did it") 41. The killings escalate. The Inuit leader Kaisape disguises his boat "like an iceberg floating slowly along," approaches the Norse farm and sets it alight: "Kaisape filled up the doorway with fuel, and then stuck fire to it, so that all the people inside were burned" 40. Ungortok escapes and is pursued and killed with a charmed arrow. Kaisape cuts off the dead man's arm and, holding it up, "repeated his own words, 'Behold this arm, which thou wilt surely never forget!'" 40.
Other tales in Rink's Danish collection remember a fight on the ice and the end of the old Kavdlunait at a place called Arsut; one tells of Norse fathers and children who fled onto breaking ice and drowned 41. An eighteenth-century tradition recorded by the missionary Niels Egede holds that foreign pirates attacked the Norse, that the survivors sailed south, and that Inuit took in Norse women and children 45. None of this can be dated or checked against the archaeology, and Rix's caution applies to all of it 42. But it is the only account of the encounter from the Inuit side, and it does not remember a gift. It remembers a feud, fought between neighbours who knew each other's names.
The bill, counted
The documented cost of the encounter is:
- Eighteen Norse men killed and two boys enslaved, in the single annal entry of 1379 2824.
- Unknown numbers of Inuit and Norse killed in the feuds the Inuit tales remember, none of which can be dated or counted 4041.
- The end of a society of up to about 2,000 people, in the Western Settlement around 1400 and the Eastern Settlement in the fifteenth century, by death, departure or both, with no surviving record of its last generation 91012.
- The serial depletion of the walrus populations of western Greenland and the High Arctic, hunted for an export trade that took smaller animals at greater distances 15.
- The disappearance of the Tuniit around 1300, in the same centuries and the same waters — a cost that belongs to the Thule expansion and the changing Arctic, not to the Norse, and that no evidence attributes to them 38.
The afterlife: the search that began a colony
The largest cost was paid later, and by the Inuit. In 1721 the Norwegian-Danish priest Hans Egede sailed for Greenland on the ship Haabet as missionary and governor. The Danish Encyclopedia's entry on him is direct: he went "med en vision om at genoplive [nordboernes] gamle bygder med dansk-norske bosættere" — with a vision of reviving the Norse settlers' old settlements with Danish-Norwegian colonists 43. He did not find the Norse, who had been gone for nearly three centuries. He found the Kalaallit, and among them founded the mission and trading colony that became Godthåb, modern Nuuk 43.
The colonial century that followed began with an epidemic. "En koppeepidemi 1733-1734 dræbte størstedelen af befolkningen omkring Godthåb," the same entry records — a smallpox epidemic in 1733–1734 killed the greater part of the population around Godthåb 43. Older accounts give larger totals for the whole colonised coast; no modern demographic estimate was located for this record, and none is offered here. Greenland remained a Danish colony until 1953, and gained home rule in 1979.
The lost Norse were the reason given. A colony that had vanished in the fifteenth century became the justification for one that began in the eighteenth, among the descendants of the people who had outlasted it. The Kalaallit who live in Greenland today are the heirs of the Thule who crossed the Arctic in the thirteenth century 3. The Norse left them some iron, a few carvings, perhaps a name, and a story about a burning house. Their European successors used the story of the Norse to take the country.
What followed
-
1200Thule people, the ancestors of the Inuit, reach north-west Greenland after a migration across the Canadian Arctic from Alaska that took a century or two.
-
1250Thule winter houses on Skraeling Island, Ellesmere, fill with Norse chain mail, ship rivets, woollen cloth and iron blades, one of the largest concentrations of Norse material in North America.
-
1300Three Norsemen build cairns on Kingittorsuaq near Upernavik and carve their names in runes, roughly a thousand kilometres north of the nearest Norse farm.
-
1300The last Tuniit (Dorset) population of the eastern Arctic disappears, within a century or two of the Thule arrival, leaving no genetic trace in the Inuit.
-
1300A Thule carver on south Baffin Island makes a five-centimetre wooden figure of a person in a European hooded tunic with a cross on the chest.
-
1300Thule people winter at Sandhavn, a harbour beside the Norse farm of Herjolfsnes, in what may have been a trading place between the two peoples.
-
1340An arrowhead of Cape York meteoritic iron, made in the Arctic, reaches a Norse farm in the Western Settlement before 1350.
-
1350Ívar Bárðarson's expedition finds the Western Settlement without people, "Christian or heathen", only wild cattle and sheep.
-
1379The Icelandic annals record that skrælingar attacked the Greenlanders, killed eighteen men and took two boys as thralls: the only written record of Norse–Inuit violence.
-
1400Radiocarbon dates put the final depopulation of the Western Settlement around 1400.
-
1408A wedding in Hvalsey church and a letter issued at Garðar the following April are the last written records of Norse Greenland.
-
1450The Eastern Settlement is abandoned; no record survives of how its last people died or where they went.
-
1721Hans Egede sails to Greenland to find the lost Norse and revive their settlements, and founds the Danish colony among the Kalaallit instead.
-
1733A smallpox epidemic kills the greater part of the Kalaallit population around the new colony of Godthåb.
-
1860Hinrich Rink and the artist Aron of Kangeq record and illustrate the Kalaallit tales of the Kavdlunait, the only account of the encounter from the Inuit side.
Where this lives today
References
- Friesen, T. Max, and Owen K. Mason, eds. The Oxford Handbook of the Prehistoric Arctic. New York: Oxford University Press, 2016. en
- Friesen, T. Max, and Charles D. Arnold. "The Timing of the Thule Migration: New Dates from the Western Canadian Arctic." American Antiquity 73, no. 3 (2008): 527–538. en
- Raghavan, Maanasa, et al. "The Genetic Prehistory of the New World Arctic." Science 345, no. 6200 (2014): 1255832. en
- National Museum of Denmark (Nationalmuseet), SILA Arctic Centre. "Prehistory of Greenland: Thule." Copenhagen: Nationalmuseet, n.d. en
- Gulløv, Hans Christian. "The Nature of Contact between Native Greenlanders and Norse." Journal of the North Atlantic 1 (2008): 16–24. en
- Buchwald, Vagn Fabritius. Ancient Iron and Slags in Greenland. Meddelelser om Grønland, Man & Society 26. Copenhagen: Danish Polar Center, 2001. en
- Historia Norwegie. Edited by Inger Ekrem and Lars Boje Mortensen, translated by Peter Fisher. Copenhagen: Museum Tusculanum Press, 2003. la primary
- Gulløv, Hans Christian, and Martin Appelt. "Tunit, Norsemen and Inuit in Thirteenth-Century Northwest Greenland: Dorset between the Devil and the Deep Sea." In The Northern World, AD 900–1400, edited by Herbert Maschner, Owen Mason and Robert McGhee, 300–320. Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press, 2009. en
- Lynnerup, Niels. The Greenland Norse: A Biological-Anthropological Study. Meddelelser om Grønland, Man & Society 24. Copenhagen: Danish Polar Center, 1998. en
- Arneborg, Jette. "Det europæiske landnam: Nordboerne i Grønland, 985–1450 e.v.t." In Grønlands forhistorie, edited by Hans Christian Gulløv, 219–280. København: Gyldendal, 2004. da
- Barr, Susan, Per G. Norseng and Nils Petter Thuesen. "Grønlands eldre historie." Store norske leksikon. Oslo: Foreningen Store norske leksikon. no
- Arneborg, Jette, Niels Lynnerup, Jan Heinemeier, Jeppe Møhl, Niels Rud and Árný E. Sveinbjörnsdóttir. "Norse Greenland Dietary Economy ca. AD 980–ca. AD 1450: Introduction." Journal of the North Atlantic Special Volume 3 (2012): 1–39. en
- Nelson, D. Erle, Jan Heinemeier, Niels Lynnerup, Árný E. Sveinbjörnsdóttir and Jette Arneborg. "An Isotopic Analysis of the Diet of the Greenland Norse." Journal of the North Atlantic Special Volume 3 (2012): 93–118. en
- Star, Bastiaan, James H. Barrett, Agata T. Gondek and Sanne Boessenkool. "Ancient DNA Reveals the Chronology of Walrus Ivory Trade from Norse Greenland." Proceedings of the Royal Society B 285, no. 1884 (2018): 20180978. en
- Barrett, James H., Sanne Boessenkool, Catherine J. Kneale, Tamsin C. O'Connell and Bastiaan Star. "Ecological Globalisation, Serial Depletion and the Medieval Trade of Walrus Rostra." Quaternary Science Reviews 229 (2020): 106122. en
- Ruiz-Puerta, Emily J., et al. "Greenland Norse Walrus Exploitation Deep into the Arctic." Science Advances 10, no. 39 (2024): eadq4127. en
- Imer, Lisbeth M. Peasants and Prayers: The Inscriptions of Norse Greenland. Odense and Copenhagen: University Press of Southern Denmark and National Museum of Denmark, 2017. (Runestone GR 1, Kingittorsuaq.) en primary
- Schledermann, Peter. "Notes on Norse Finds from the East Coast of Ellesmere Island, N.W.T." Arctic 33, no. 3 (1980): 454–463. en primary
- Schledermann, Peter, and Karen M. McCullough. "Inuit-Norse Contact in the Smith Sound Region." In Contact, Continuity and Collapse: The Norse Colonization of the North Atlantic, edited by James H. Barrett. Studies in the Early Middle Ages 5. Turnhout: Brepols, 2003. en
- Sutherland, Patricia D. "Strands of Culture Contact: Dorset-Norse Interactions in the Canadian Eastern Arctic." In Identities and Cultural Contacts in the Arctic, edited by Martin Appelt, Joel Berglund and Hans Christian Gulløv. Copenhagen: Danish National Museum and Danish Polar Center, 2000. en
- Sabo, Deborah, and George Sabo III. "A Possible Thule Carving of a Viking from Baffin Island, N.W.T." Canadian Journal of Archaeology 2 (1978): 33–42. en primary
- Golding, Kirsty A., Ian A. Simpson, J. Edward Schofield and Kevin J. Edwards. "Norse–Inuit Interaction and Landscape Change in Southern Greenland? A Geochronological, Pedological, and Palynological Investigation." Geoarchaeology 26, no. 3 (2011): 315–345. en
- Jackson, Rowan, Jette Arneborg, Andrew Dugmore, Christian Madsen, Tom McGovern, Konrad Smiarowski and Richard Streeter. "Disequilibrium, Adaptation, and the Norse Settlement of Greenland." Human Ecology 46, no. 5 (2018): 665–684. en
- Dugmore, Andrew J., Thomas H. McGovern, Orri Vésteinsson, Jette Arneborg, Richard Streeter and Christian Keller. "Cultural Adaptation, Compounding Vulnerabilities and Conjunctures in Norse Greenland." Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 109, no. 10 (2012): 3658–3663. en
- McGhee, Robert. "Contact between Native North Americans and the Medieval Norse: A Review of the Evidence." American Antiquity 49, no. 1 (1984): 4–26. en
- Nelson, D. Erle, Niels Lynnerup and Jette Arneborg. "A First Isotopic Dietary Study of the Greenlandic Thule Culture." Journal of the North Atlantic Special Volume 3 (2012): 51–64. en
- Ívar Bárðarson. Det gamle Grønlands beskrivelse af Ívar Bárðarson (Ivar Bårdssøn). Edited by Finnur Jónsson. København: Levin & Munksgaard, 1930. (Sixteenth-century Danish translation of a lost fourteenth-century Norse original; quoted from "Ivar Bårdsson", Store norske leksikon.) da primary
- Storm, Gustav, ed. Islandske Annaler indtil 1578. Christiania: Det norske historiske Kildeskriftfond, 1888. Gottskalks Annaler, s.a. 1379, p. 364. non primary
- Arneborg, Jette. "Qaqortukulooq kirkeruin." Den Store Danske (lex.dk). København: Lex.dk. da
- Nyegaard, Georg. "Restoration of the Hvalsey Fjord Church." Journal of the North Atlantic Special Volume 2 (2009–10): 7–18. en
- Nørlund, Poul. "Buried Norsemen at Herjolfsnes: An Archaeological and Historical Study." Meddelelser om Grønland 67. Copenhagen: C. A. Reitzel, 1924. Facsimile, Copenhagen: Museum Tusculanum Press, 2016. en primary
- McGovern, Thomas H. "Cows, Harp Seals, and Churchbells: Adaptation and Extinction in Norse Greenland." Human Ecology 8, no. 3 (1980): 245–275. en
- Diamond, Jared. Collapse: How Societies Choose to Fail or Succeed. New York: Viking, 2005. en
- Berglund, Joel. "Did the Medieval Norse Society in Greenland Really Fail?" In Questioning Collapse: Human Resilience, Ecological Vulnerability, and the Aftermath of Empire, edited by Patricia A. McAnany and Norman Yoffee, 45–69. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2010. en
- Dugmore, Andrew J., Christian Keller and Thomas H. McGovern. "Norse Greenland Settlement: Reflections on Climate Change, Trade, and the Contrasting Fates of Human Settlements in the North Atlantic Islands." Arctic Anthropology 44, no. 1 (2007): 12–36. en
- Zhao, Boyang, Isla S. Castañeda, Jeffrey M. Salacup, Elizabeth K. Thomas, William C. Daniels, Tobias Schneider, Gregory A. de Wet and Raymond S. Bradley. "Prolonged Drying Trend Coincident with the Demise of Norse Settlement in Southern Greenland." Science Advances 8, no. 12 (2022): eabm4346. en
- Nedkvitne, Arnved. Norse Greenland: Viking Peasants in the Arctic. London: Routledge, 2019. en
- Arneborg, Jette. "The Norse Settlement of Greenland." In The Cambridge History of the Polar Regions, edited by Adrian Howkins and Peder Roberts, 129–152. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2023. en
- Seaver, Kirsten A. The Frozen Echo: Greenland and the Exploration of North America, ca. A.D. 1000–1500. Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1996. en
- Rink, Henry [Hinrich]. Tales and Traditions of the Eskimo, with a Sketch of Their Habits, Religion, Language and Other Peculiarities. Edited by Robert Brown. Edinburgh and London: William Blackwood and Sons, 1875. Tale 54, "Stories about the Ancient Kavdlunait", pp. 308–321. en primary
- Rink, Hinrich, ed. Eskimoiske Eventyr og Sagn. Kjøbenhavn: C. A. Reitzel, 1866. Tales 67–71. da primary
- Rix, Robert W. The Vanished Settlers of Greenland: In Search of a Legend and Its Legacy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2023. en
- Olesen, Simon Mølholm, and Hans Christian Gulløv. "Hans Egede." Den Store Danske (lex.dk). København: Lex.dk. da
- Hayeur Smith, Michèle, Kevin P. Smith and Gørill Nilsen. "Dorset, Norse, or Thule? Technological Transfers, Marine Mammal Contamination, and AMS Dating of Spun Yarn and Textiles from the Eastern Canadian Arctic." Journal of Archaeological Science 96 (2018): 162–174. en
- Egede, Niels. "Beskrivelse over Grønland" (written c. 1769–70). Edited by H. Ostermann. Meddelelser om Grønland 120 (1939): 233–269. da primary
- Madsen, Christian Koch, and Ann Eileen Lennert. "Behind the Ice: The Archaeology of Nunatarsuaq, Southwest Greenland." Journal of the North Atlantic 42 (2022): 1–32. en